Good stuff everyone - @jordan_229 - your recipient / volunteer has asked if you still want to do a swap, if not, no problem as this was a duplication for them anyway. Cheers!

1 Like

Ah I think i was confused and didn’t think I had one as I hadn’t received the name. Might as well leave it now and I’ll get involved next year :+1:

1 Like

Sent!

5 Likes

Good job, sounds like it was a trial getting it organised!

Wasn’t too bad once I remembered you can buy postage online - just had to take a trek today to get to a post box.

Also the artwork came out totally the wrong size when I printed it from my tablet as I couldn’t get my laptop to connect to my mum’s printer, oh well.

1 Like

will jump in first with my feedback of the cd which I have deduced must be from @maggieloveshopey, which came with a warning about the noisey start of the cd with a song by Svalbard. I’m mostly not too keen on noise, but the song itself is quite promising, as it pretty much sounds like Mew, with even a little bit of Mew-like singing in a couple of parts of it. Unfortunately it just has a man shouting all over most of the rest of the song! :smiley:

I think my first (compilation) cd I bought as a kid was a reggae album, and I still have fond memories of Sweat (A La La La Long), but I think that album is where my love of reggae started and ended, so I wasn’t too keen on Indica Dubs.

Next is Waxahatchee, who seem to be loved by many. I think I tried their album in 2020, but it didn’t click with me enough to listen more. Was pleased to have another go, and I like the song, but not enough to go back to the album just yet.

I like the next two songs from Obey Robots and Slotface, but the Slotface song is definitely more immediate and catchy and makes me want to go to an indie rocky disco and just jump about relentlessly (well, for 3 minutes 46 seconds).

I’ve seen Jeff Rosenstock’s name on this board, and think I’ve checked him about because of that, but it doesn’t grab me that much.

HC McEntire is very country/americana, although mostly country. I’ve had a bit of fondness for some country music (more than reggae!), but this song doesn’t have anything else that jumps out for me.

Jon Brooks is next, and is my favourite track of the cd so far. It’s just really nice and dreamy - it’s a simple sort of keyboard tune throughout most of it, but it’s very good. Will definitely have to check out his album.

Bow Church - Not really got anything to say about this song, but it’s good.

Cunning Folk - Ooh, this one’s my favourite of the cd I think. I like the electro-folk-noodling of it. Sounds like a relation of Akron/Family’s first album. I hope their album is of a similar sort of sound! (although I may have been happy without the last 3 minutes of the 9 minutes 30 of the song :smiley: )

Lightning Orchestra possibly has too much going on for me to fully enjoy, although I don’t dislike it. Maybe like a soundtrack to some crazy goings on in a movie or something.

I can’t quite tell what I make of Upsammy. I sort of like it, but it’s also a bit too unsettling for it to click with me properly.

Aha! AA Williams is the one artist that I have properly heard, and have actually bought and really enjoyed her album. I started listening to this song on your cd, trying to remind myself which song it was, and then I remembered your shouting Svalbard song which made me realise that it was going to be the shouting AA Williams song! :smiley:

and finally Sadness, with this almost 12 minute long beast of a song. Post-rock guitarry stuff (is my detailed description), and somehow hasn’t been on my radar despite listening to the cd a fair few times now, but I’m definitely liking it now that I’m properly paying attention to it. Lovely. (not sure whether you’ve listened to the album last year from the band Happyness? Just to have a nice spectrum of emotional band names!)

Thank you very much for the cd and songs! Especially as I only really knew one of the songs, and it’s so good hearing a bunch of new songs instead of the ones I’d been playing to death already. A nice mix of songs, and even the ones I wasn’t initially as keen on have still grown on me a bit. Looking forward to checking out the albums for a few of them to see what their other songs are like! thanks again! :slight_smile:

5 Likes

Aw, cheers! Yours has had a couple of listens, but I need to give it at least one more before I commit any thoughts to paper. Hopefully by the end of the weekend…

2 Likes

Nice to see some feedback at last, sounds like a good one (I’ve certainly heard more of those)!

1 Like

Heard none of those…

and a promised here are my thoughts on the CD which turned out to be from @paulo13

Destroyer are one of those bands who have been on my radar for a long time but I’ve just never paid much attention to. This tune is okay but I can’t help thinking if you’re going to call your band Destroyer you should be doing something a bit meatier than inoffensive synth pop.

Thanya Eyer is a new name to me. I like the percussion on this one, and the passage toward the end when it goes all woozy. One to investigate further.

I was also previously unfamiliar with Jonathan Bree. I’m going to stop saying that, because there are very few artists on this mix I previously knew (which is kind of the point, right?) There’s a sort of synthesised loucheness to this one, a seedy Jacques Brel recording on Garageband vibe, which I like.

This Alexandra Saviour track has a similar feel, with a dark carnival undercurrent. It’s my favourite of this section of the disc - it’s of a piece with the previous tracks but is a lot more successful for me.

The next track is my least favourite so far though! It’s not like there’s especially wrong with NMANDI, but it’s just a bit nothing. I’ve listened to it a few times now and can’t find anything to hang on to.

Up next, Noiserv have some nice touches, another one with a good percussion element, but ultimately there’s not a lot in the song itself to grab me.

Kraków Loves Adana offer a good strong track. Simple, pretty much just a synth bassline, and a couple of pads and melodies winding around it, but it works really well. One of my favourites on the mix.

Spinvis is another one that largely passes me by I’m afraid.

Spirit Fest - The Snow Falls On Everyone has a good country / folky groove, and actually puts in mind of the HC McEntire track on my mix - they’re both kind of rustic takes on motorik (if you squint a bit). There’s nice metallic twang to the lead instrument as well - I think it’s an acoustic guitar but it sounds almost like a banjo. Another good track .

The Delmar Darlon came in like it was going to be an M83 style synthy shoe gaze kind of thing and my interest was piqued, but unfortunately that first minute is the best part of the song for me.

Those vocals in the chorus of the Austra track are an interesting choice, aren’t they? I hated them on first listen, but over time they are growing on me.

TSHA - I like that nagging insistent instrumental break that comes in a few times. This is a superior slice of dance pop, digging it quite a bit. Not really what I associate with Ninja Tune, I remember when it was all head nodding spliff addled bollocks

The Cocorosie (at last! An act I do know!) track is another one I like. I think it benefits from being allowed to stretch out over five plus minutes (you’ll have seen from my disc that I like a long song, and you’ll probably be grateful when I tell you I had to cut a 20 minute track in the final cull). A lot of the songs so far have been little vignettes or cameos, and it’s nice to have something take it’s time a bit more.

Alex Mayr is more Europop, another to file under “doesn’t do much for me”

Sault, of course, is one I knew in advance, and an act that almost made it onto my own mix. This is a highlight, with a really smart piano part throughout.

This Sevdaliza song is a bit goth, you know. And that’s fine with me. Listening to the rest of her latest album as I type this out.

Jazzier late night vibes with DakhaBraka, at least until….I always like records that sound like two different things at once. I bet this would be great at a festival!

Not, however, so keen on Lyra Pramuk’s vocal layering and layering, and by “not so keen” I mean “this is the sort of thing they play in Hell”.

The penultimate track is Dino Brandeo and his mates. Another hmmm one, I’m afraid

…and we close with Evening Hymns, which is a great choice for the final cut. It has that woozy melancholy tiredness to it that seems to go on forever, like when you’re shattered and sprawled on the sofa as the day ebbs away.

There’s a definite mood and type of song throughout here, I suppose you’d call it something like contemporary singer songwriter / alternative pop? You’ll have figured from my mix that it’s not the kind of thing I normally listen to. I usually prefer a bit something a bit sloppier and rougher over the kind of poised sophistication we have here, but that’s not to say I’m not open to it. There are a good five or six artists here I’ll make an effort to hear some more by. It’s hard to say why one track grabs me and another doesn’t, but that ineffable alchemy is what makes music so good, isn’t it? I also noted that there’s what seems to be a lot of European music here, and I’m curious how you discover it all? Any good blogs etc, or is it all just Spotify recs and so on? Anyway, thanks very much for compiling and sending the disc! I got to hear loads of things I wouldn’t have otherwise, and like I said about five thousand words ago, that’s the point!

2 Likes

Thanks for the feedback - especially as you had twenty of them to go through!
As for my selection, it is a lot more European than precious years - although previously my European bands would all come from Scandinavia, so I’m not sure why they’ve dropped off my radar last year. It’s been a while since I’ve read blogs for my music, but I do make an effort to check out my Discover Weekly playlist on Spotify every week, and follow any bands that I like, and so mostly find albums that way or have them pop up again at random points in the future. Would almost be a bit lost without that now (and the DiS weekly releases threads). Probably three quarters of my tracks were all new discoveries for me this year!

Krakow Loves Adana were probably a spotify-found band, and their album (and so) this year grew on me lots, so definitely worth checking out if you like this song. Glad you liked the Austra song - the chorus could easily be annoying, but I find it so catchy. And the Evening Hymns album is a lovely set of 8 or so songs along that relaxed warm mind of vibe. The Delmer Darion album might still be worth checking out, just because they have a few different sounding songs on the album, and I probably picked the one more that matches more my style than yours!

Anyway, thanks again! :slight_smile:

2 Likes

Mine has arrived. I’m guessing it’s from @Icarus-Smicarus?

Really chuffed - from 20 tracks there are only three that I’m familiar with, and they’re all very good (RTJ, Phoebe Bridgers and This is the Kit). I’m looking forward to getting stuck in this afternoon.

1 Like

yep, that’s me and my comically small front and back cover! good to see the village postbox actually gets collected.

2 Likes

Anybody not received a mix? (I know I haven’t, and I think there may be one or two others)…

there’s probably one lying on my hall floor but i won’t find out for another couple of weeks

1 Like

I lost the packaging for mine with the reindeer name but this one came in a brown sleeve with a BUFF sticker.

This was full of stuff I should have heard already this year but hadn’t. I had only heard the RTJ track (although it wasn’t my favourite one on that album).

My favourite tracks were Luke Abbott, Holy Fuck, Jessie Ware, Taylor Swift and Fourtet. I actually hadn’t realised HF and Fourtet had music out last year (although I have now discovered both). The HAIM one was a bit of a pleasant surprise too.

The SAULT track was OK but I’m not sure how keen I am on either of those albums from last year. I fee like I want them to be less polished I think.

Thanks!

1 Like

BUMP - We’re into February now, so time for that feedback to start rolling in! What did you enjoy, what didn’t you, etc!

1 Like

I haven’t managed to be very active on here recently so don’t think I’m going to have much chance of guessing my mix partner but whoever you are thank you very much for a very enjoyable and interesting mix. Roughly a 50/50 split of artists I like or knew of and unknowns.

Great start with Midwife. I loved Like Author, Like Daughter but it completely passed me by that they had released a new one this year. Doesn’t sound like they have drastically changed their sound so one to add to the shopping list.

Of the three more emo/punk songs that followed my enjoyment progressed as they went on. Dikembe had a bit too much of the chugging guitar riffs that I’m not really of a fan of, Thank You, I’m Sorry was slightly veered too far into twee but I liked Gulfer and the chiming intertwining guitars.

Sinai Vessel was a big favourite. I have looked him/them up and seen the links with Lomelda & Hovvdy and can see that in this track. Another one to pick up on Bandcamp Friday at the end of the week.

From the middle run the big highlight for me was MJ Guider. Feels like bit of a darker twist on dream pop with the vocals buried just at the right level. Hoping the album is more of this sound.

I couldn’t really get past the vocals on Black Wing & Arca. Think I would have enjoyed them more if they were instrumentals. Ben Chatwin would not be something I would stick on at home but I would imagine this would sound pretty huge cranked up. Aesop Rock again is not something I would usually choose to listen to. I’ve seen the name a lot on this site and never investigated further but this is fantastic. Really addictive and one I had to keep putting on repeat. Love the production on it, warm but crisp sounding. Is the new one a good place to start with him?

Even after multiple listens I’m still unsure on Active Child. Find the chamber pop kind of grates on me a bit but the beautiful strings always pull me back in.

From the more ambient run to the end it’s only really Son Lux that didn’t really do anything for me and again it’s down to the vocals I really need to give the Sufjan album more time. It just hasn’t clicked with me yet but in fairness I haven’t given it the time it probably needs. Rone is another hit. Still always think a beat is going to come in and it’s going to lift off but it’s another lovely sounding track.

I got the Mary Lattimore & Julianna Barwick albums quite late on in the year and if I’d had another month to make this mix they would have easily have featured in my top 20.

Phil Tomsett was nice enough but didn’t really grab me but Ian William Craig did. Another name I’ve seen a lot of on here but never pursued. Beautiful voice and flutters of distortion.

So thanks again, a very high hit rate with lots of things to investigate further!

2 Likes

Hi Dusty,

Very glad to hear there were some stuff on there that you enjoyed, I often do a kind of indie one and electronic ambient one, so found it tricky cutting it down to one disc, and I know I’d sort of thrown a barrage of my 3 or 4 favourite genres on there, so would never expect it all to hit. Plus I do love a lot of artists that perhaps don’t have traditional or even normal vocals (lots of noridic accents and the like),

new Midwife’s great, bit short unfortuantely but great, MJ guider is pretty much that sound for sure, deep buried vocals under fuzzy shoegazing indie electronics. I’ve always loved Aesops albums but the last 3; Skelethon, Impossible Kid and Spirit World Field Guide take that small but significant step into, I guess, a more indie territory. Impossible Kid is my favourite, his vocabulary is immense and there’s a lot of nostalgic nods and humour in there. But Spirit World would be a fine place to start and make your way backwards from, if you enjoy it. I know many don’t but i actually really like the Sufjan album, I guess it’s more my bag, although I’d put Seven swans as my favourite it’s up the top there for me, I get easily bored of too much acoustic guitar and enjoy the electronic backing. Also the album came out one of those big life moments for me and the album topic was on point. Love the Rone album, one of my favourites of last year, lots of beat but calming and reflective at the same time and really reminds me of listening to Banco de Gaia in my teens.

Thank you so much for my mix - I got hit by Covid just in to the new year and between that, work and teaching the kids, I’ve been wiped out a bit, but back to myself now, so I will pick it up again, I had a couple of listens just after christmas and thoroughly enjoyed it, very mellow and calming but with tempo too, similarly about half and half i know, I used to be more heavily devoted to the genres of your mix, and found it warming and nostalgic, proper feedback to come soon. Thanks

alright i know it’s March now but i’ve been locked down at my parents’ for longer than expected and only just made it back to my usual address for a bit. had this waiting for me behind the door

i only really know the Mogwai and RTJ tracks (i’ve heard the AA Williams album but can’t remember much about it) so will be interesting to dive into the rest.

unlike my own mixes, this looks mercifully nice and short, which i appreciate a lot, as hypocritcal of me as it is.

i’ll get this listened to it in the next few days and get some feedback posted. no idea who it’s from so far!

5 Likes