A Thread To Judge Whether A Christmas Song Is Good Or Not

  • G
  • B

0 voters

  • Good
  • I have no soul

0 voters

  • Good
  • Bad

0 voters

  • Good
  • Bad

0 voters

Quite afraid to press play on this

I have said ‘good song’ to some of these because the option:

Objectively good but I please god never ever let me hear this fucking song ever again!

was not an available. This would apply, for example, to Wham.

Yeah I was scrolling angrily to check because it’s the best Christmas pop song.

1 Like

Carol of the Bells

  • Good
  • Bad
  • Good but I am anxious that the big action finalé is about to kick off.

0 voters

Annoyingly with these ones I have no definitive recording anywhere but God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen is a favourite one.

  • Good
  • Great

0 voters

Tempted to close this while it is, justifiably, still at 100%

  • Actually Good
  • No

0 voters

One of the girlfriends in the Last Christmas video went to my dad’s primary school!

That’s why Jack Charlton called me up for international duty with Wham.

3 Likes

That one’s rubbish, Cool Yule on the other hand…

ZAAT YOU SANTA CLAAAUUUWWWS??!

it’s amazing

Even by the standard of Xmas songs, this is a right stinker (not that I’d say that to Joe Pesci’s face :confused:)

  • Good
  • No

0 voters