#41

Narrowing this down to five was hard, but Pearl Jam is an easy number one. They have one of the best and deepest discographies out of any band. It’s ridiculous how underrated they are. The idea of limiting myself to one song off of each album is too stressful, so here’s Immortality.

It’s hard to put such a new, small discography against so many old, deep ones, but if I could pick any band to wake up to a surprise album by tomorrow, it would be Palm Haze. Possibly the most exciting shoegaze I’ve ever heard.

Protomartyr is one of the few best bands of last decade, and Relatives in Descent is a top ten album of that period.

Not much left to say about the Pixies.

I’m fairly new to Pavement, only having heard an album by them for the first time six years ago. They’re going to get the last spot because Slanted and Enchanted and Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain were instant classics, and it should probably count for something that they managed to make me love a song that is rude to my musical hero.

1 Like
#42

The two toughest omissions are probably Parquet Courts and Pedro the Lion. It feels very wrong not being able to include both.

Some of these are really hard to leave out too. In no real order:
Pile
Phoebe Bridgers
A Perfect Circle
PJ Harvey
Post Louis
Priests
A Place to Bury Strangers
Pelican

#43

P is pain…

  1. Prince
  2. Pink Floyd
  3. Plaid
  4. Pye Corner Audio
  5. Petrels

Please release me:
Panda Bear, Parliament, Patrick Duff, Patrick Doyle, Paul Draper, Paul Leonard-Morgan, Pavement, Peaches, Peeping Tom, Penguin Cafe, Penthouse, Perturbator, Peter Broderick, Peter Gabriel, Pet Shop Boys, Phil Campbell, Phoenix, Pia Fraus, Pinkshinyultrablast, Pity Sex, Pixies, Plone, Plyci, Poemss, Pop Will Eat Itself, Porcupine Tree, Portishead, The Postal Service, Pram, Prefab Sprout, Prefuse 73, Primal Scream, Prins Thomas, Procol Harum, The Prodigy, Propellerheads, Public Service Broadcasting, Pulp, Purity Ring…

#44

Polvo
Pavement
Pile
Protomartyr
Pinback

1 Like
#45

Pavement
PJ Harvey
Pixies
Parliament
Purple Mountains

#46

Portishead
Pinback
PJ Harvey
Pet Shop Boys
Pulp

#47

Pavement
Parquet Courts
Portishead
Phoebe Bridgers
Protomartyr

#48

Portishead
Parquet Courts
Pavement
Pixies
Pulp

#49

PJ Harvey
Patti Smith
Portishead
Parliament
Public Enemy

#50

Jeez, tough one

  1. Pulp
  2. Pixies
  3. Pop Will Eat Itself
  4. The Prodigy
  5. The Phantom Band

Apologies to Pains of Being Pure at Heart, Parliament, Public Enemy ,Primal Scream , Pet Shop Boys, Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, Public Service Broadcasting and Paris Angels

#51

Pedro the lion
Paul jebanassam
Pinback
Petrels
Pavement

1 Like
#52
  1. The Polyphonic Spree
  2. Pulp
  3. The Postal Service
  4. Psapp
  5. Point Juncture, WA
#53

Forgot Polmo Polpo.

1 Like
#54

Another top 10 listing from me:

First five

PJ Harvey
Pale Saints
Pixies (Kim Deal line -up)
Psychedelic Furs
Piano Magic

Next Five:
Puressence
pg.lost
Pauline Murray and the Invisible Girls
Propaganda
The Passage

That’s my playlist for today sorted.

1 Like
#55

Ah, Propaganda! Duel is an amazing song!

1 Like
#56

Pixies
Pavement
Public Enemy
Prince
The Pastels

1 Like
#57

Paramore
PUP
The Presidents of the United States of America
Portishead
Prince

#58

Pulp
Parquet Courts
Prince
Patti Smith
Portishead

#59

Yeah, tough letter.

First 5:

Pete & the Pirates
PJ Harvey
Palace (Music/Brothers/Whatever)
Phosphorecent
Penthouse

Next 5:

Pixies
Peaches
Plush
Pissed Jeans
Pulled Apart By Horses

1 Like
#60

Yeah. Essentially one album and a million remixes in their classic line-up. But what an album.

1 Like