Alternative hot takes thread - smashing pumpkins chat allowed

#1

:jack_o_lantern:

#2

No.

#3

Please elaborate

#4

Machina is bad. It’s just bad. About 3 good songs, horribly produced, shite concept.

Mutes thread.

2 Likes
#5
#6

I’ll pm you!

3 Likes
#7
#8

Lotr references are list in me, I think it’s overratted

#9

Feels like we’ve come nicely full circle here. The rolling Smashing Pumpkins thread was the best (if not the original?) hot takes thread

1 Like
#10

This is now the cinema hot takes thread!

1 Like
#11

I quite enjoy the Smashing Pumpkins greatest hits album. Anything past that, nah you’re alright thanks. Cheers!

1 Like
#12

What are your feelings on the Judas O bonus disc?

#13

nods and smiles I think it would be a good idea.

4 Likes
#14

“I’d have to say, the Best of the Smashing Pumpkins”

3 Likes
#15

AT LEAST HARRY POTTER HAS A PROPER STORY
IN THE SENSE THAT THE CHARACTERS CRAVE AN ENDING
IF ONLY TO RELEASE POOR BILLY CORGAN
FROM THE ROLE AS THE TITULAR CHARACTER’S NEMESIS

1 Like
#16

I hadn’t thought about the smashing pumpkins in years before posting on DiS properly. Now I think about them constantly and they punctuate my dreams. It’s awful.
I mean no disrespect to people invested in them and enjoy the early stuff fine.

2 Likes
#17

You’re welcome!

2 Likes
#18

As a result of the constant Smashing Pumpkins chat on here I gave a good try at listening to the whole of Mellon Collie and I think I got over half-way. And it was better than I had expected, better than Siamese Dream I think. But still I am baffled by the intense popularity of this band who aren’t Radiohead.

1 Like
#19

The answers in that second half

2 Likes
#20

Just because