Artists whose biggest songs are also their best

Kind of an antithesis of this thread, and indeed running contrary to the entire “I preferred their earlier stuff” spirit of DiS, what are examples of artists biggest songs which are also in your opinion their strongest?

Inspired by listening to Built to Spill, where Carry the Zero is so obviously their best song and quite rightly their most popular.
Love pretty much all of Arab Strap’s stuff for a variety of reasons, but if I could only listen to one of theirs it would probably be First Big Weekend.
Sabotage - Beastie Boys
Chicago - Sufjan Stevens (Spotify stats don’t bear this out as being his biggest, but I’d still say it’s his signature song)
Waiting Room - Fugazi

Shoot…

3 Likes

The Rat

35 Likes

(Good call on Fugazi)

3 Likes

Mr brightside
One-armed scissor

10 Likes

Built to Spill - Carry the Zero :x:
Arab Strap - First Big Weekend :white_check_mark:
Beastie Boys - Sabotage :white_check_mark: (but happy to be told I’m wrong with this one)
Sufjan Stevens - Chicago :person_shrugging:
Fugazi - Waiting Room :x:

1 Like

Radiohead - Creep

I’m Blue by Eiffel 65

17 Likes

Just A Day by Feeder
Romantic Rights by DFA1979

2 Likes

Move Your Body erasure, this

1 Like

Float On (applies to both Modest Mouse and The Floaters)

1 Like

Pump Up The Volume.

What’s the matter, too challenging for all you Anitina (The First Time I See She Dance) stans?

2 Likes

refused - new noise

9 Likes

Bon Jovi - Livin’ on a Prayer

1 Like

No that’s the worst one

2 Likes

Dua Lipa - Don’t Start Now

give over, i’ve heard freedom

Loads of better Fugazi songs than Waiting Room, however it is the only one of theirs that stands to reason as to why its their most popular song if that makes sense. Basically most justified but not best

1 Like

The Whole Of The Moon by The Waterboys

16 Likes

Granted I just mean on that album, which is why I suggested it on the prior thread, its obviously better than everything else they put out (except maybe Rather Be Dead)

One of the best nu-metal songs thats for sure :wink: