Like I said in the other thread, Gish through Machina II is my favorite run of albums by any band ever (and songs in general, when you include the massive amount of b-sides and demos and unreleased songs). All of them are all time classics IMO.
If you remove the expectations and don't compare them to what came before, Zeitgeist and Oceania are great. I think they'd be more appreciated if he changed the production style and went back to his pre-singing-lessons style of singing. Monuments is fine and a very good "just throw it on" album, it's just not special like the early ones and the quality of the lyrics is far, far, far below what he's capable of.