šŸŽø Ballad of a Thin Man: the Dylan Listening Club - Shot of Love (1981) - from post 1122

two for the playlist The Times They Are A- Changin’

  • The Times They Are A-Changin’
  • Ballad of Hollis Brown
  • With God On Our Side
  • One Too Many Mornings
  • North Country Blues
  • Only A Pawn in Their Game
  • Boots of Spanish Leather
  • When the Ship Comes In
  • The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll
  • Restless Farewell
0 voters

I really love this version of When The Ship Comes in from I’m Not There. Very pure and hopeful

1 Like

Another 8.5 album for me the highs are high but there’s some filler here and some that quite don’t make the mark.

Beginning the think maybe I don’t like Bob Dylan as much as I thought I do

Disappointed for you ma man :sob::cry:

6 Likes

Yeah, as an album this one is a bit of a slog. It’s very downbeat. And, musically, it’s about as minimal as he can get. Can’t fault the lyrics though of course!

1 Like

Ah, this is really interesting. I’ve heard The Pogues version on Rum, Sodomy & The Lash too, but the parallels are much clearer when you hear The Dubliners doing it.

I thought I knew The Times They Are A Changing well, but Restless Farewell was the one song I didn’t remember when revisiting this week. I thought it had that ā€œfeatured in a Boston policeman’s wake movie sceneā€ vibe and now after reading your post, that makes perfect sense!

1 Like

I actually heard Dylan’s first (at least consciously) and didn’t know the Parting Glass connection for a long time so The Parting Glass always sounds like a weird cover to me and I have to remind myself it’s the other way round.

Same with his non-album track Farewell from this period (as heard in Inside Llewyn Davis) which is basically a version of The Leaving of Liverpool, but I was a Dylan nerd long before I listened to much trad or Pogues

1 Like

Sad to see North Country Blues on zero votes, it’s brilliant

2 Likes

10/10. The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll radicalized me.

8 Likes

It’s very funny that John Lennon wore that hat for like 6 months because he was so in love with Dylan

1 Like

Have to take it all back, what an incredible album. ā€˜Boots of Spanish Leather’ is the only dud on it, everything else is gold.

This Post Paid For By PROF$.

3 Likes

God these tenor gif’s are terrible, get it together sean.

10 Likes

The genius of the man is you have a perfectly fine version of One Too Many Mornings of this record. And know I know, I keep harping on Hard Rain. But just listen to this version of, blows the studio version on this record to absolute smithereens.

3 Likes

I know it’s a retread of ā€˜Girl From The North Country’ for a reason but that song is so much better.

ā€˜Restless Farewell’ isn’t great either actually. A shame to end the album on that note after so many bangers. ā€˜One Too Many Mornings’ is a triumph.

This Post Paid For By PROF$.

1 Like

YESSSSSSSSSSSS

This Post Paid For By PROF$.

1 Like

Le Hard Rain

1 Like

Amazing how he can do the same song so differently so many years apart and they’re both fucking brilliant.

This Post Paid For By PROF$.

4 Likes

oooofffttt

And let’s not forget about this guy

Basement tapes Bob might just be my favourite Bob.

4 Likes

I’m liking all these alt versions and keen to dive into them. So keep them (and other outtake tracks) coming!