🎸 Ballad of a Thin Man: the Dylan Listening Club - WE'RE DONE - roundup and results from post 1758

Yeah this is his worst period, combination of shite novelty songs and really limp songwriting. Also this one has dated worse than the mid 80s ones which at least sound awful in a novel way.

It’s very Bob to follow up a genuinely great album that sounds like it could have been made yesterday with this.

Next few weeks are gonna be a tad uninspiring.

1 Like

The next few albums are purely covers I think?

Never listened properly but I think they’re solo acoustic as well so can’t be that bad surely

They’re much better than this but totally average

Think this is the first one, Dylan aside, that I don’t know anything at all from before giving it a go.

Have actually found most of the earlier maligned albums better than I expected, admittedly thanks to low expectations, and had hoped this might be the same…

Nah. Real stinker isn’t it. So phoned-in. Maybe still not actively unpleasant to listen to for the most part but very little there.

Don’t even find it funny and/or interesting like some of his other career mis steps. Just plodding.

Some of it might be passable as curios in an offcuts collection, but very few of these songs sound like they belong on a proper release.

Kindest thing I can say is that there’s a light and breezy quality on Side B - 2 x 2, Handy Dandy, Cat’s In The Well - where he sounds like he’s enjoying himself. Dunno what the touring set-up was like at the time but might’ve been fun. They’re not really genuinely decent songs though.

3 Likes

Not really coming round to it but ‘Born In Time’ is actually a great song tbf

Some lovely alternate versions too

1 Like

Yeah, UTRS is a bit naff really. Shame, as the version of “Born In Time” up there ^ is really good, but the one that made the album is an absolute shambles. Neither Bob nor whoever he has producing seem to know what they’re doing at any point.

“Oh Mercy” on the other hand is a genuine classic. I’ve always loved it in a vacuum (“Most of the Time” made my top 10 in the What’s Their Best Song: Bob Dylan thread!) but its quality seems downright miraculous now given the dreck either side of it.

But then that’s all part of what makes Bob so weird and delightful, I suppose!

yeah this is really poor and so disappointing after a return to form as such with oh mercy.

God this is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO shit!

35 mins long and outstays it’s welcome by about half an hour

Him going from Oh Mercy to this is as baffling as going from ‘Dylan’ in 1973 to ‘Blood On The Tracks’ 2 years later

Back to mum posting

Great Oh Mercy sequence - everything is broken, ring them bells, man in the long black coat, most of the time

2 Likes

haven’t even though of this one again since my first listen. Oh well - vote it!

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
  • Wiggle Wiggle
  • Under The Red Sky
  • Unbelievable
  • Born In Time
  • T.V. Talkin’ Song
  • 10,000 Men
  • 2 X 2
  • God Knows
  • Handy Dandy
  • Cat’s In The Well
0 voters

and next up Good As I Been To You

oh

After recording Under the Red Sky in 1990, Dylan would not release an original song until 1997, and during that time, he would increasingly rely on his stockpile of covers for ‘fresh’ material.

hadn’t realised quite had terrible Knocked Out Loaded went down :smiley:

huge improvement on UTRS but then that wouldn’t be hard. Listened to the first 5 tracks or so before getting to work and have quite enjoyed it. Nice to hear him acoustic again.

The same man who wrote Desolation Row wrote Wiggle Wiggle. Worth remembering if you ever truly fuck up at work that this nadir may only be in contrast to absolutely skyscraping heights you are capable of scaling… or that your best days are long behind you and you’ve become an embarrassment to yourself and Slash.

4 Likes

UTRS - think the title track and Born in Time are both perfectly decent and sweet, really like the accordion wheezing away in the background of the former. TV Talkin’ at least sounds like he’s in a good bar band, I’d hang in a dive bar listening to this, and 2x2 and God Knows are a listenable pairing

Very little of value otherwise and some of his lowest lows so far. Sad!

It’s a step up but I imagine it was super depressing being a Dylan fan in the early 90s. No sign of new material and just a series of unremarkable covers albums. I think it says a lot that I’ve never seen a single song from this or World Gone Wrong on any of his compilations - they are absolutely memory-holed.

That being said, it’s not an awful record. It goes down easy, it’s just kind of uninspired. At least his other covers era (the Sinatra years) was a completely mad swerve that he went completely overboard on.

I would disagree. There’s so many great songs and very frank ones on time out of mind

Was almost ready to dip out when I saw we had two albums of covers now and the first was nearly an hour long

But a few tracks in and this is actually a pretty pleasurable listen. Gravelly Bob with his acoustic guitar, what’s not to like

I didn’t mind this, don’t get me wrong it’s bad. But imo better the those two 80s albums