I reckon if Devo finished with New Traditionalists and just disappeared, they’d be viewed with more unanimous esteem.
Conversely, I reckon if Jeff Magnum and his International Soft Men (Neutral Milk Hotel) had kept ploughing out material, they’d never have anything close to the reputation that they have. Would be seen with the same vaguely-positive meh-ness of Beirut.
Caveat that Modest Mouse are still great but can you imagine how they’d be regarded if they’d split after Moon and Antarctica? They’d probably be touring just as busily right now but as a culty reunion band
was just thinking the same for Dino Jr, but they have gone so hard into the new music that it’s hard to think of them as a nostalgia circuit band in even theory
I think if Interpol had gone Bright Lights, Antics, and then put out a statement that said ‘without Carlos D we refuse to continue’ (let’s ignore he left one album later) then I think people would already be elevating them above landfill/NYC thing.
“Janet Weiss has informed us that she no longer wants to continue in the band, and as she is an indelible part of both our sound and fraternity we have decided to accordingly bring our reunion to an end.”
Pumpkins would be seen as all timers if they split after Mellon Collie. People pretend Adora and Machina are good but they’re not really and no one ever puts them on
Their post reunion output puts them in the category of ‘actually bad’