from who, me personally or DiS/wider internet in general?
Can’t speak for anyone else but I tend to pick things I think I will like anyway, so there’s a decent chance I’m at least expecting a 7 or 8 out of 10 going in as a base score, and then see if they better, hit or miss that target. In general, because I tend to pick stuff I think I’ll like or am enthusiastic about trying, I tend to get good results, but not always. I’d wager most writers do this tbh.