Best different song of the same title - ULTIMATE FIGHT POLL


Time to pit two all-time great songs against each other:


  • Metallica
  • U2

0 voters


You forgot the Beach Boys! But my vote would still go to Steely Dan.


Cathy’s Clown

  • The Everly Brothers
  • You Am I

0 voters


Very close.


I realised afterwards, but alas it was to late to edit it.



Beach Boys


I’m really surprised by the results of this one. I thought Pearl Jam would have been running away with it.


Polls with more than two choices can sometimes produce surprising results. It may well be that Pearl Jam would win against M83 in a two-way contest.


Yeah that’s true, especially here since Pearl Jam and the Pumpkins have a pretty considerable overlap in fans. I don’t even know which one to vote for right now - my gut tells me the Pumpkins (of course) but then I remember that McCready solo.


what is wrong with you all


Wow lots missing here


Could people do a quick spotify check before posting? Just dont think people are treating it seriously enough


My thoughts exactly. The right one in the lead, of course, but how does bloody Huey Lewis get any votes at all??? One of the most pointless bands of the 1980s.


You mean check before posting the poll, or before voting?

If the latter, I have abstained from many of these because I was unfamiliar with most of the selections. I could give each one a listen of course, but I think it’s hardly fair to vote on the basis of one listen, so I leave it to those who know the songs well.

  • Jordyn Jones - All I Need
  • Radiohead - All I Need
  • Air - All I Need
  • Daniel Avery - All I Need
  • Jack Wagner - All I Need

0 voters


I Kissed a Girl

  • Jill Sobule
  • Katy Perry

0 voters



  • The Kinks
  • Manic Street Preachers
  • The Shins

0 voters



  • Helloween
  • Sonic youth
  • Mudhoney
  • Misfits
  • Dave matthews band
  • Siouxsie and the banshees
  • Dead kennedys
  • Mastodon
  • Matt pond pa

0 voters


My bloody valentine