The old boards are a double edged sword.
On the one hand they bring in a lot of traffic. About 10% of the site traffic this year (which obviously considering how active these forums are, they generate a lot more page views with everyone darting back and forth). Some of the top pages this year on the old forum have had 20-50k visits, and there are 1000s of pages which get at least 500 impressions a year.
There wouldn’t be too much to lose by getting rid of them but it’s all run on the same database as the articles archive, and I have to think whether I can justify just deleting 100s of peoples’ contributions, the bulk of which are linked to from artist websites and wikipedia, etc. It’d be scrapping the entire history of everything I’ve spent my adult life doing. I’m not sure I’m ready to do that.
On the upside, we get a few people every week trying to get us to delete things from the old forum and I’m sure a lot of people would prefer if it was gone - and currently we can’t delete it all.
The other consideration is the cost of paying a developer to make these changes, and the short term lose of traffic to all of those pages, which generate a bit of ad revenue and help us find new users…
It’s a lot to consider and I’ve been wrestling with it for a few years now.