Cities With Great Music Scenes

I’m curious what your local scene is like, how it has changed, and if you had some sort of Sim City powers, what you would do to improve the scene?

Reason for asking is because I had a really interesting chat on the Drowned in Sound podcast with former DiS contributor Shain Shapiro, who’s now an advisor to various mayors and governments on their music policy. We talked a fair bit about initiatives that foster community and he shared a lot a fair few insights into the next 25 years (as DiS turns 25 this year, one of my plans for the podcast this year is to look at what music might be like in 2050 and to produce my findings from all of these chats)

I’m also trying to find examples of music scenes to visit that might give some clues of how things should be. I always love going to Glasgow for this reason (feels like a lot more independent orgs have a strong footing) and has always felt like Nottingham’s scene has been lovely to dip into, but like all of these things, I think it’s about who you know in a city that really skews your perception of it. I’m going to Tallinn in a few weeks, which I hear has a good music scene but it’ll be during a conference, so probably as hard as making sense of Austin during SXSW or Groningen during ESNS.

If anyone fancies a listen, the podcast is on YouTube here (first time uploading a full episode) or wherever you get your podcasts. Last week’s issue was a chat with Frances Fox from Climate Live and the week before with the CEO of Youth Music (dovetails with what Ezra Collective had to say at BRITs).

Going to give you a long answer about Cork when I’m at my laptop.

This Post Paid For By PROF$.

3 Likes

I would guess that the short answer as to what makes a city have a great music scene would be that aspiring musicians need somewhere to play in public while they’re still honing their craft, and many cities have seen the types of venues that would do that slowly priced out of the property market and therefore lost or are losing their scenes.

4 Likes

I feel like you may have asked something similar before, or maybe I’ve answered something similar before, or maybe I just go on about the Brighton music scene all the time and it all blurs into one.

Anyway, he should visit Brighton for https://www.homegrownbrighton.co.uk/ festival, where a fantastic cross section of the local talent will be playing all the local grass roots venues.

The scene isn’t built around one venue or band. There are three core venues - Green Door Store, the Hope & Ruin and the Prince Albert, and a bunch of smaller venues like Rossi Bar, Daltons and Folklore Rooms which help the upcoming bands play gigs more appropriate to their size. Best of all most of them are within about half a kilometre of each other. A lot of musicians play in multiple bands, and the scene has thrown out at least three top forty debut albums in the last twelve months (Lambrini Girls, Ditz and Lime Garden). If Van Zon and Big Long Sun haven’t broken out outside of Brighton in the next year I’ll eat my hat.

3 Likes

Montréal

1 Like

I don’t go out much to local gigs but I do teach film at two local universities, mostly documentary. Every year we get at least three documentaries made about how great and open and welcoming and diverse and interesting and supportive Bristol’s music scene is for live, improv, DJ, jazz, and beyond. Is there anything crucial-sounding in the 10+ films I’ve seen? No. But in terms of participation, barriers to being locally-recognised, places to play from DIY to professional. Things are tied together by attitude rather than genre, so pretty much every band is queer-friendly if not actively featuring performers across the sexuality and gender panorama. Utopian.

7 Likes

Edinburgh says hello. Feels like there’s a bit of a buzz every 10 years or so, everyone thinking a scene is about to take off. Then the council and landlords have their way and everyone gets an office job or moves to Glasgow instead.

3 Likes

That actually surprises me as I would have thought the fringe scene in Edinburgh is so integral to the city that it would HAVE to have something in place to support DIY scenes.

Don’t know why I still have the capacity to be surprised by the actions of landlords and city councils, but apparently I do/did…

1 Like

There’s a few small venues that have survived for a while now, but there’s never really been any acts or genres that people have coalesced around to form a scene. (Also, I’m not sure if your mention of ‘fringe’ alludes to the festival, but the fest is very much not for Edinburgh-based acts and is a probably a net negative for foundational/diy arts venues in the city.)

3 Likes

It’s a bit more than that though - venues are great but you need a network of promoters to put good shows on, labels to release music, and local media to spotlight stuff and get people excited. My experience of living in a couple of major UK cities is that most places will have the first, some will have the second, and where the last exists very few people care because the national media sucks in everything.

2 Likes

@Kallgeese has already said he’ll reply later

1 Like

Oh, FFS. I can’t even blame that on autocorrect from my phone

2 Likes

a weird one here though is that I’m not even sure if there’s been a Glasgow scene as such in the last … 15 years? it’s much better for gigs, touring bands, more experimental stuff of course - but doesn’t feel like it’s led to local bands that have actually broken through

i started uni in what was the last great Scottish indie moment, when you had Frabbit, Phantom Band, Twilight Sad, King Creosote, Meursault (so underrated) all popping up and in my head that was just “Scottish music” doing well rather than thinking of it being city-based. And so many of the current good bands I like have membership split across the central belt, or with someone up in Dundee etc

dunno, feels like a country with a population of ours and the two biggest cities so close together - maybe its just too connected to have distinct city identities (at least now especially with the internet). There’s lots of good band around now, feels like it’s better than it was 5 years back even in terms of quality, but yeah fractured and a bit loose rather than being tied to a central vital venue like The Windmill or label or whatever

also god bless Sneaky Pete’s for keeping us semi-relevant!

3 Likes

all that said, did get this in my recommendations and need to check it out

4 Likes

And if you don’t have those, then you can have all the venues you want but if 90% of their gigs are tribute bands and half the clubnights are Britpop related is that really a thriving live music scene?

4 Likes

I may have done because it changes and people go on trips or move to different places. Always fascinated by the answers.

With the implosion of local media, finding those clued up and passionate people to celebrate their local scene feels harder than ever (hence this thread)

Tbf, I think very few acts have really broken through for a decade, which is part of a wider issue with “new music”

1 Like

Was actually about to share this video. I went to this last Wednesday and had a great time. I checked out some of the names in that video and it seems there are fairly regular gigs to be had both at nights like Attack Release in Glasgow and then there’s Wavetable and Frequency Shift in Edinburgh.

There’s also the Glasgow Library of Synthesized Sound CIC and Signal Sounds (also Glasgow) that seem to be encouraging people to get involved and try to make music of their own.

I’m guessing the experimental electronic ‘scene’ is small in the grand scheme of things, but there seems to be plenty of community in place to support people making this kind of music, which is really cool. It’s more of a ‘scene’ than anything I was involved in when playing in bands in central Scotland the last couple of decades.

1 Like

That all sounds awesome man, thanks for sharing. Wasn’t aware of those Edinburgh ones so will have to investigate - as well as maybe meet up at the Glasgow one in future?

Did it feel more like a gig or club night? Cos I’d love to experience some of the stuff that gets played at e.g. Sneakys club nights, but just not built to go to those nights often …