Time for my thoughts on @Icarus-Smicarus’ mix. First off, sorry this has taken me ages, but there’s just so much of it….a full 22 tracks, making my twelve or so look like an EP or one of Kanye’s twenty minute “albums”.

I think Thee Oh Sees are one of the best live bands around right now (possibly the coldest take ever on DiS), but never really been sold on them on record. This is a good one, though, a proper banger right out of the gate to kick us off. Then a bit if eroding from The Comet Is Coming. I never got on with this album, which is a shame because I really liked the last one. The Flatworms track is really good, loving the urgency of that driving bassline. Twilight Sad feels really eighties, like Mike Scott’s Big Music gone bit goth, and there are some good squelches on the Battles track. Pretty Eyes is good, has that same trick of making noise effervescent that Parts & Labor did. Really liked Ty Segall around the time of Manipulator, but couldn’t keep up with everything he was putting out. Quite like this one, I should check out the album.

Squarehead are completely new to me, and this is pretty decent, with a big influence from classic US indie rock. Tandem Felix are another unknown. After the first minute or so I was going to write it off, but it picks up at the end, got quite into it after all. Bonniesongs is another new name. For the first thirty seconds or so I was liking this, thinking it was going to be a treat…and then the vocals came in, and I don’t think I’ll be listening to any more from Bonniesongs. Shame, because musically this is one of my favourites so far.

Moving on, we are back in the realm of artists I have heard of. Rozi Plain is someone I’ve always meant to check out. Seen her a few times playing with This Is The Kit, but somehow never got round to her solo records. Definitely in the same ballpark as the Kit, this is another poke to go and try them out. On to the Flamingods, who provided one of my favourite musical memories this year when I had an argument with someone at work about whether their name was pronounced “Flaming Gods” or more like flamingoes with a d on the end.

The Purple Mountains song is one of the few tracks here I knew beforehand. I played the album a lot on release but kind of drifted off it after a while, which is a shame because it is very good (and sad ofc). Stephen Malkmus is nice enough, but at this point I think if I was ever going to fall for his sound it would have happened by now. I was expecting a full on freak out from the Wand track, but this is a lot gentler, very pastoral. Like it.

And now we enter the final stretch with some folk. I do tend to find that a little bit of this kind of stuff goes a long way, but I did like the Shannon Lay track a lot. Alasdair Roberts is a little bit too Mulligan and O’Hare for my liking. It’s a funny one, I quite like the song and a lot of its constituent parts, but I’d like to hear a completely different take on it. I caught Lankum at a festival a couple of years ago and really enjoyed them. I already had this album, so we’re finishing on one I know. It works well as a closer, has an elegiac air of finality to it.

And there we are. Thanks so much for this, I can tell loads of work and thought went into it. Hope I haven’t come across as too negative, there was a lot I liked - will definitely listen to more from Tandem Felix, Pretty Eyes, Wand and others.

1 Like

Yeah sorry again about the length but glad there was plenty you enjoyed!

I tried to stick to albums only but couldn’t resist throwing in a track from the Flat Worms EP, though I should probably have picked Surreal New Year as the track given the time of year.

The latest one is the closest he’s got to the Manipulator sound since so could be a good one to jump back in for. 2018’s Freedom’s Goblin got a lot more acclaim but I found it a little bit bloated and the latest one quite refreshing in comparison.

I originally read their name as Flaming Gods and then noticed there was only one G so I went down a rabbit hole a while ago of watching various interviews and live sessions to try and find out which it was. Didn’t get a conclusive answer really but I presume it’s the latter, which is a shame as the former sounds much cooler.

They used to be a very freakout band but they’ve moved away from it and into more latter day Radiohead territory now. There are still some slightly louder / longer / psychier tunes on this big sprawling album but I find this track really catchy and nice too

Originally wanted to open the mix with their 10 minute version of The Wild Rover but it seemed a bit much.

Anyway thanks for taking the time and effort to write up your thoughts, much appreciated!

2 Likes

@DustyNothing - already had you rumbled as my sender with a bit of detective work. Rummaged through the box of old Dis mix discs and found a Space one you had also sent to me!

Been giving your disc lots of spins over Xmas. Wasn’t familiar with very much of the source material - a few names I’d seen mentioned on this forum which I hadn’t followed up, quite a lot I’d never heard of and a couple which I’d seen live at the summer festivals. The only artist I was very familiar with was Richard Dawson (I’d very nearly picked Two Halves as my song for your disc - but it is a bit too close to reality. I coach my son’s U10 footy a Sol Jol Park and there are plenty of bell-ends there on a Saturday morning who could be the narrator’s dad).

Highlights? Strange Ranger was very good, reminded me of Red House Painters, will be following their album up. Self Esteem - quite a swerve in style from Slow Club, but clearly a lot of fun (and I’m seeing her live this weekend at Rockaway Beach fest). Wasn’t quite sure about Bonniesongs at the start, but the song definitely went in a interesting (and unexpected) direction and ended up a winner. Helado Negro sounded like a good Devandra Banhart (rather than the smug, self-satisfied Devendra Banhart), another album I’ll be listening to. I’d had a FKA Twigs song on a previous Dis mix CD which wasn’t to my liking so hadn’t followed her up. But her song to end your disc is a belter so will give her new record a listen.

Saw Rozi Plain at the Reading Abbey festival last summer (and I’ve seen This Is the Kit before). Can’t put my finger on it as she’s doing lots of good things but the music doesn’t do it for me. Also saw Squid last summer at eotr, they were interesting but (a bit like the two big Speedy Wunderground artists Black Midi and Black County New Rd) I actually prefer the idea of them to how they actually sound.

Overall it was a great disc, and as usual with these swaps opened my up to some new music I wouldn’t have otherwise heard. Thanks!

2 Likes

Don’t know Squid but I agree on the other two. Think they’re both up my street musically but I’m not a massive fan of the vocals (I’ve only heard one BCNR song so far though)

1 Like

Good work, been doing these for years so thought we would have been matched up at some point!

Glad you find some new bits to enjoy and most of what you did ended up being my number 1, 2 & 3 records of the year. I ended up putting Strange Ranger first. I Feel like I’m doing them bit of a disservice when I write that it’s nothing more than just a very good Indie Rock album. It doesn’t really push any boundaries but it hits the sweet spot for me of melodic melancholy that’s got a bit of a slacker, rough round the edges feel to it. I wasn’t the biggest Slow Club fan so didn’t rush out to investigate this record as I thought it would be of a similar ilk. It was only when I saw the word banger being constantly used on here to describe it that I finally checked it out. I managed to catch her live a couple of months ago and it just highlighted how fun the record is so hope you enjoyed her at the weekend. Helado Negro was a new one on me. Seems like he’s got bit of a back catalogue but again thanks to these boards I checked out the latest album which ended up sound tracking my summer.

The Bonniesongs track is the most immediate on the album and not truly reflective of it. If you found that had enough interesting twists in it you’ll probably enjoy the rest of the album even more. I find the new FKA Twigs has some of the best and worst stuff she’s done but glad this has peaked enough of your interest to give it a go.

I kind of feel the same about King Gizzard on your mix (more feedback to follow) that you do about Rozi Plain on mine. I’m not sure I’m completely convinced about the hyperbole around Squid but I did choose to see them over sheltering from the rain at Green Man this year and I’m glad I did. They lifted my sodden spirits and I enjoyed the EP. Intrigued enough to see what they can do across a full length.

Thanks very much for the feedback, something I haven’t always got back when doing these mixes so always appreciative when someone takes the time to report back.

2 Likes

Some delayed feedback for my Santa (hope Prancer received yours )
Really enjoyed this (double) CD & have been going back to it pretty consistently.
There’s a good mix of some personal favourites, some artists that I’m aware of without being too familiar & some stuff I’d never heard of before.
Mix starts out great with These New Puritans. I really enjoyed Hidden at the time, but haven’t kept up on their progress. I’ve gone back to check this album out & it’s really good - a winner already.
International Teachers Of Pop were completely new to me. While I quite enjoyed this track, it hasn’t perked my curiosity enough to seek out the whole album yet.
The William Doyle track was a nice surprise, I really enjoyed one of his albums as East India Youth a few years back. I need to check this album out, I’ve not done so yet but I do intend to.
The new Elbow album is very good & The Delayed 3:15 is a good selection. I’ve not spent loads of time with the record but I’ve enjoyed every listen.
That Siobhan Wilson track is lovely… must check that out. She has a lovely voice.
I’ve never quite gotten on with Jane Weaver in the past to be honest, just hasn’t clicked for me & I’ve tried… although I absolutley loved this belter of a tune (Element).
The Fat White Family track was enjoyable, but didn’t really grab me enough to want to investigate further.
Aldous Harding is one of my favourite current artists & Fixture Picture is one of the singles of the year for me.
That Twilight Sad version of Floating In The Forth is incredible & a very poignant way to wrap up Disc one.

The opening track on Disc two kind of passes me by to be honest… Unloved indeed :slight_smile: Not a bad song by any stretch, just that there’s better on the way.
Movies by Weyes Blood is one of my absolute favourite songs of the year, although to be honest I think that album has been overpraised a touch.
The next track (The Night Life) has also been passing me by, again possibly because there’s another cracker on the way. It’s interesting for sure, but hasn’t really pulled me in.
That Hot Chip album is right up there with their best for me & No God is a great tune.
I absolutely loved that Tiny Ruins record & was lucky enough to see her live recently. Have you heard the solo version of the album with just guitar & vocals? Possibly even better. She reminds me of Nick Drake in the best ways possible.
I’ve given the Lankum album a few goes & while I can appreciate them, it’s not been sticking. Perhaps I need to see them live - I can imagine this working in a live setting.
I wan’t too keen on Working Man’s Teeth to be honest - one that I’ve been skipping.
That Richard Dawson tune though. Wow. I’ve been aware of how well regarded he is… and by lots of people on DIS whose opinions I respect, but I’ve not gelled on previous listens. Two Halves did the trick though… and I’ve enjoyed going back to the record since.
The Stealing Sheep track is pleasant enough, but halfway through I’ve been getting the urge to listen to Richard Dawson again!

Anyway, thanks so much for a wonderfully curated mix. I still have much unpacking to do from it.
Happy New Year!

2 Likes

@Prob500 Thanks very much for the mix. Mainly a mixture of unknowns and vaguely heard of’s for me but I’ve been really enjoying it.

From the few I did know or had vaguely heard of

KOKOKO, a great energetic start to your mix. I’d checked out a couple of songs after seeing them being added to the Green Man line up. Really liked what I heard but decided not to go any further as it would be nice to see someone over the weekend I wasn’t over familiar with. Then they went and pulled out on the day they were meant to play! A nice reminder that I still need to check out the album in full.

I love the Oh Sees. New album hadn’t clicked that much with me until the last few weeks. If I was doing my mix now it would definitely be bumping out someone.

Our only overlap Richard Dawson. Could have picked anything of the album but think I went with Two Halves due to timing constraints and the fact that it’s a bloody good song! I’ve had bit of an involvement in youth football and can see where you’re coming from. I’ll steer clear of Sol Jol Park!

I’m a big Silver Jews fans but I can’t remember whether it just got buried in a pile of other new releases or the tragic news put me off listening for a while but your mix made me realise in the end I never got round to getting it at all.

Snapped Ankles were another Green Man find at 2am and I think I was a bit harsh at filing them as better live than on record as I really enjoyed this.

Familiar with some of the Wave Pictures stuff but not in any kind of detail and not any of their collaborations. Liked the downbeat, ramshackle nature of this one and cracking guitar solo.

Trash Kit was a big highlight. I’m fairly sure one of them has had something to do with Rozi Plain’s band which made me check them out earlier in the year. Beautiful guitar work and a rare lengthy song that I wouldn’t mind being a bit longer!

The Complete Unknowns

I was a little unsure of Christian Fitness, Viagra Boys and Jeffery Lewis at first. All seemed to have a slightly comedic feel that I felt might grate on me over time especially when the more wordy highbrow Richard Dawson was sandwiched in the middle of them. In the end it’s had the opposite effect and it’s probably my favourite run of songs on the mix. I now eagerly await the, what I initially thought was a slightly silly and grandiose, This is your Captain speaking interlude. I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve just randomly shouted out Weiner dog and the bouncing 60’s garage rock riff of LP’s is never out of my head for long.

As I mentioned on my feedback there are maybe a few where I feel like I should like them, they have all the elements of other stuff I like but from what I’ve heard so far they don’t really do anything for me. King Gizzard being the main one from your mix. I see they have a rather daunting back catalogue and I’m fairly sure that if you pulled out certain songs from each record it would make an LP I could love but I don’t think I have the time to do so.

Amyl & The Sniffers sounded like how I expected them to sound like from the name and it was okay. I could see how they could be good fun live. I liked the guitar on Hey Colossus but not the vocals so much and in a similar sense might have enjoyed the Bonnacons of Doom track without the albeit limited vocals.

The only two I didn’t really get on with were Anna Meredith & Titus Andronicus. Both of which I’ve tried after seeing them lauded on here but they are just not for me.

That’s a very high success rate so thanks again and thanks to @funkycow for reviving the mix and sorting this all out.

2 Likes

Thanks for the nice feedback, glad you got something out of it. Must admit I was slightly concerned how it would go down after getting yours as I mainly stacked it with ones that went up to 11 whereas yours was a much more sedate mix.

The king gizz track is pretty unrepresentative of their sound as the album it is from is a thrash metal pastiche (albeit one done with great skill and love). My favourite albums of theirs are the cosmic space jams - mind fuzz and nonagon infinity - so if you can bear to listen to them again start there.

Titus andronicus are one of my favourite bands but unfortunately their quality control dropped off a cliff a couple of years ago. The song I included is one of the better ones from last year’s album (and where the singer fully indulges his inner Springsteen) but if you haven’t done The Monitor give it a go, it’ll easily be in my top 5 albums of the last decade.

Thanks again for the feedback.

I second @Prob500’s album picks above but reckon if there’s one song that will tell you if King Gizzard for you or not it’s probably this one

(they’ve got quiter stuff in their catalogue as well but it’s generally not as good imo)

meant to post this ages ago but i made mine into a Spotify playlist in the unlikely event anyone else might be interested in it

2 Likes

So everyone, would you like me to try and resurrect mixtape club (theme based) this year? Perhaps quarterly?

4 Likes

RIGHT! Big apologies to Blitzen (who I think is @static?) I’ve had a mad Christmas/January and trying to settle back into a routine, so I do have feedback on some of the stuff you sent, thank you!

First of all, the generosity of 3 CDs was quite something, thank you for that, very much appreciated. I’ve sadly only listened to 2 of them, I hope that will suffice for now!

From Mostly Guitar and Mostly Electronic…

  • Loved the Greet Death track, just my sort of thing, the sombre build and lovely bit of fuzzing guitar.
  • Likewise, Pedro The Lion was really cool as well - I think I picked up the album from BSM PWYW sale, so will look forward to checking the rest of that out.
  • Good choice of Microwave track (heck, anything off that album would have sufficed, likewise the BATS track, glad to see we gave each other different tracks from both those albums!)
  • The Peaer track was unusual, but decent - will have a look out for the album.
  • The Good Sleepy track was fucking ace and right up my street, love the strained shouty vocals and the widdly widdly bits.
  • 52 Hertz was bloody great, think I’ve actually downloaded that but not got round to listening to it properly.
  • Seagull was interesting… not sure if it’s for me, but it kept my attention.
  • Couldn’t get into the Cross Record track, sorry - I tried but it was bumming me out too much.
  • Jaques Greene was really chilled out and blissful (actually found most of the Electronica one really great to listen to at night whilst driving).
  • Big fan of the Jon Hopkins/Kelly Lee Owens track, loved the beats on this.
  • Malibu Ken was hilarious, was not expecting that - just terrific and bizarre. :smiley:
  • Giant Swan was odd…not sure if I got it to begin with, but it’s really grown on me, very industrial-esque.

Sorry for the delay. I will try and get to the ambient record, honest!

1 Like

Yes - I’d be into this.

1 Like

I would also be in for this!

1 Like

Hey Shucks, no apologies needed obviously, I’ve been in the same situation work/kids and the rest, and I also threw loads at you, certainly wasn’t expecting feed back on all 3. (just figured I’d hit 3 possible targets and I think it was a good year of varied stuff last year) I still had to do a fair bit of cutting, particularly on the ambient one, that could of been 4 hours by itself.

It’s great that you found some stuff you liked, and obviously no worries on anything you didn’t - I go for the scattergun approach and I do love a bit of depressing lofi folky indie now and again, and the cross record and seagull tracks fit that bill for me but not gonna be for everyone.

I really enjoy that greet death album, other than bats probably my most listened to guitar album of the year, I think having the 2 singers alternating throughout the album keeps it interesting too. and happy to hear you liked good sleepy, it’s got those midwest emo vibes going on (my favourite kinda/ the good kinda emo) a la Algernon Cadwallader, Empire!, Empire! and the like.

loved Pedro… for years but was suprised by the new album, because I hadn’t massively gelled with his solo stuff lately (but this was more reminiscent of his older stuff, and I particularly like the second half)
should note his album Control is one of my top 5 albums of all time.

Figured you might go for 52 hertz when I got your mix as that other than bats is the most post hardcore band on there, but yeah completely solid up and coming band.

Really glad you got something out of the electronic album too, one of my favourite things is that kinda slow beat vocal electronica (probably the stuff hidden in the middle a bit) but glad it went down alright and yeah that Malibu Ken tracks hilarious, Aesop rock is the lyric master, worth checking out his last album the impossible kid which I think is brilliant and work your way back if you like that.

Apolgies for my lateness too of course, I always want to do proper justice to the feedback and then end up doing it off the top like I am now.

Overall nothing not to enjoy with your mix the whole thing builds really nicely and keeps the energy up right to the end which is really saying something.

I had a mate many years ago who listened to way too much macc lads and I think that perhaps put me off more british sounding vocals across most genres but definitely apparent in the more up tempo post punk styles, so although enjoyable in the mix the more british bands like snapped ankles, christian fitness and USA nails are the ones I’d be less likely to delve into further.

Good shout on bats and microwave for sure, at one point I had ‘we are all going to die’ by Spielbergs on mine too, (really reminds me of kennedy by the wedding present), so definitely some similar branches there. Good to hear the instantly recognizable tones of Bob Mould as well - hadn’t really heard the new stuff, but copper blue was a big love back in the day.

The tracks that stands out for me and that I’ve digged further into the Album/Ep for are

  • Sugar Horse - nice slow opener with a good hidden bite to it, nice tempo changes and has a good mix of styles, bit of shoegazey durge and guitar noodling, what’s not to love, I’d say this and Sofy Major are my favourite finds or more appropriately gifts on here.

  • False Bliss - nicely winds up the tempo and intersting blend of styles across the track and their album.

  • ILS - probably overall a little too screamo for me beyond the one track but great here, I adore a small handfull of screamo stuff, namely trachimbrod, suis la lune and 52 hertz, but they all have either dual singers (one non screamo) or in the case of Suis la Lune kinda adopt that style, and the instrumentals are ridiculously tight. But do enjoy this track in situe a lot, I’d recommend checking out State Faults - Clairvoyant from last year if you haven’t already, it’s got a very similar full on screamo energy vibe.

  • Urochromes - my favourite of the more post punk stuff for sure. Got that swagger to it.

  • Sofy Major - big solid riffs, good bit of variety in the sound across the album, can do slow hard (if you know what I mean) and there’s a nice bit of something different in the vocals, tops.

  • Deafkids - definitely interesting, like prog rock on lcd/speed.

  • Austerity program - nice bit of those shellacy, fugzai, minor threat type feels.

So overall thanks both for a great mix and some solid feedback, a few there that I will definitely be keeping up with. cheers.

1 Like

Potentially up for it but will depend on having the free time or not. May dip in and out depending on theme

Perhaps we should have a “Why the Irish are great?” theme?

Ok, I’m in!

1 Like

:grin::rofl:

Yes please, was looking out for this before xmas and completely missed it.