Obviously it’d be mad to sack Southgate, and I’m not advocating it - he’s earned the right to see this trajectory continue upwards, but I reckon there could be a big decision to make after the World Cup next year if England lose to a powerhouse in the same sort of meek, deer-in-the-headlamps manner for a fourth successive time (if you’re counting the Nations League).
He deserves immense credit for getting England over historical hang-ups, and if he were to leave in the next couple of years, he’s done brilliantly to lay foundations, but that’s another missed golden opportunity. Dare I say it… it felt like Mourinho’s Spurs. Take the lead - now what?
He had absolutely no answer once Italy started taking control, playing the kind of dominant football you could never imagine Southgate’s England producing against top-class opposition like that. The chances are England will have to play two or three sides the quality of Italy next time, and I wouldn’t have much confidence of them getting through that with a coach as paralysed by fear as Southgate. Gut feeling is that he’s taken them as far as he can, and they’ll need someone else to go that next step – and with these young players coming through, that should be the aim really.
To be honest, getting to the semi-final last time and the final this time is probably about par for the players at the manager’s disposal and how the route panned out. I get it feels remarkable given the history of failure, and fair play for not repeating those mistakes, but to me it honestly isn’t “remarkable” to get to that point – when player-for-player you’re better in every position than Denmark (maybe not goalkeeper) and Ukraine, they really really ought to be winning. The “remarkable” thing is the fact they’ve failed to do that so consistently for so long up until now.
Couldn’t revel in England’s defeat cos it was horrifically brutal and they’re a GBOL, but honestly just really really happy to see a well-coached, proactive side like Italy show there’s another way to win in international football. I get the logic of Southgate looking at France and Portugal as the template, but really really glad that reactive, cautious, stunted style didn’t win for a third successive tournament. Fell in love with this Italian side from the first night of the tournament and it was lovely to see them deservedly win it.