I replay my old favourites all the time. When I was younger I replayed stuff like RE4, and MGS1-3 dozens and dozens of times. I like revisiting games too years later and noticing/understanding things I missed or confused me back then. Mgs2 in particular just fascinates me more as the years go on.
And if you told me I could never replay Silent Hill 2, Halo, Devil May Cry, Wind Waker, or Final Fantasy 7 again I’d be very upset.
I’m also very very fond of HD remasters, as it gives me an even better excuse to revisit old favourites.