I like the sound of this thread! I could do with learning what chords / notes I’m playing on the guitar if I’m totally honest

i try and think of it as maximising the sound of something. think there’s a tendency to think of it as correcting ‘errors’ in mixing but you really ought to go back to the mix if there’s stuff wrong with it. obviously loudness is a big thing but also saturation and EQ and compression.

basically play it along side stuff you like until it’s somewhere near.

2 Likes

Street Spirit?

1 Like

i’ve been trying to distill the little I know into cheat sheets. thought other people might find it useful too. haven’t QA-d it might be wrong

Borrowed chords:

to try and break out of predictable chords that are diatonic to the key you are playing in, you can borrow chords from other modes that have the same root note, most commonly borrowing chords from the minor scale in the major scale, but any of the modes can work.

in addition when moving between chords that have a space in-between (like C to Dm in the key of C major) you can fill that gap with a diminished 7 chord, and it will work (diminished 7 chords can resolve to any major or minor chord one note up or 2 steps down)

Harmonic Minor/Major

Harmonic minor just sounds super dramatic and spooky, and it has all these bonus chords that work, the F can be Major, Minor, Major/Minor, or diminished, the E can go from major to augmented, just loads of ways to work in the tension. The B diminished 7 is completely symmetrical so any of its 4 notes can become the root note and you can cascade the chord up and down, there are loads of different voicings and fragments of the chord that work really well as like add-ons to other chords, same with the C augmented 5th which any of the 3 notes can become the root.

With normal A minor you can switch to the relative major of C but that doesn’t work here as there is no G note so it is a C augmented chord, i’m not sure if they are supposed to go together but the C harmonic major scale works really well with the A harmonic minor, as it shares all the weird chords, the diminished 7ths and augmented chords.

Another bonus of those diminished 7th chords is because of their symmetrical property you can use it as a pivot chord to key change all over the place, to any major or minor chord one note up or two steps down from any of its four notes.

that is about everything I know on music theory gleaned from youtube videos, could have got it wrong though

6 Likes

This is very cool, need to have a play with this

1 Like

might try and set it up in excel so I can select a root note from a dropdown and populate the tables

Have improved a lot on the old pots & pans over lockdown

OR SO I THOUGHT

Been playing at home a lot on a digital kit. Finally had a band practice last week for the first time in 6 months and couldn’t wait to put my ideas into practice on a real kit.

I was dreadful. A real drum kit really is very different to electronic isn’t it?!

Dust in the Wind

My mastering chain at the moment (in Audacity because free is the best flavour) is a very simple EQ (https://www.pluginboutique.com/product/2-Effects/16-EQ/358-Baxter-EQ), a stereo widener (http://www.alexhilton.net/A1AUDIO/index.php/a1stereocontrol) and this tape-ish compressor/limter/saturation plug-in (https://www.kvraudio.com/product/ferrictds---tape-dynamics-simulator-by-variety-of-sound).

Like you said, just dork about until it sounds like stuff you like, if it still doesn’t then go and fix it in the mix. Biggest learning for me regarding mastering is to mix much, much quieter beforehand so you’ve got headroom to work with.

@Scott_Chegg

1 Like

Thank you & @ericVII

I’m on Logic Pro X, but gonna make the switch to Audacity soon because it just seems…better?

never quite got this, surely it only matters if you’re squashing transients and overcompressing or limiting? otherwise just bounce and knock it down 6db?

Ah, but you assume a level of competence I do not have!

I literally bounce nothing and limit/compress basically not at all. There’s a lot I need to learn, tbh. I found that previously (and this is a mix issue) I was having to compress too much to get things to gel, and I was losing dynamics horrifically as a result. For some reason this workflow seems to work for me, but maybe it’s actually more of a ‘learn to mix’ issue.

I did this in Studio One Prime and mastered it in Audacity - no one’s heard it except me so I’d be happy to hear if there’s any pointers you’d have (outside of my crummy performance obv) because I’d like to start building a bigger project around it and any feedback is helpful. (Of course you don’t have to!)

  • I am very methodical at learning a new thing or process
  • If I don’t nail it within 5 minutes I will just play something I know instead

0 voters

There is no middle ground

ha well i’m no mastering engineer, i really only do it for myself out of necessity. i give my albums proper to the pros for which there is no substitue imo, they have far better gear than the few plugins most of us have.

but i think a bit of general advice would be not to halfway house it. i’m probably being a purist but i just think it’s better workflow to print a mix you’re happy with and master it separately. otherwise i think there’s a temptation to twiddle and tweak mixes and mastering settings constantly resulting in a lot of back and forth. it’s a bit putting the cart before the horse.

Yeah, 100 per cent agree. Good advice (also yeah, if you can afford it give it the pros, definitely. I used to work with a mastering engineer who mainly spoke in what I considered to be some sort of elf language for all the sense it made to me)

I am sooooo shit at this stuff, like across everything I’ve never been good with formulas or equations or anything

Just don’t understand scales, or modes or any of that stuff, have tried to learn a bit and just instantly forget

:face_with_head_bandage:

When I’m struggling with stuff it helps to remind myself that is all totally arbitrary and really music theory is just a common language we use to describe stuff that sounds a certain way. Even octaves and stuff - so what if it’s twice the frequency? We’ve arbitrarily decided that’s important. There are microtonal scales that don’t even have the octave in them.

1 Like

I understand the very first paragraph is and then I’m just :pouting_cat:

I know what a chord is

2 Likes

Play stuff, does it sound good? Yeah, great. No, meh. I subscribed to the music theory reddit ages ago and it’s full of people being like, “If I know what a mixolydian mode is will I become a good musician and make $$$” and it’s like, this is the wrong way around. Unless you’re working in a field that has a really strong theory base (mid-century jazz onwards, modernist classical, blah blah blah) there’s not a huge amount you’re going to gain versus just trying a different chord or note.

I say this as someone who took loads of music lessons when I was a kid, exams, classical, jazz, did theory, a music A level, worked as a musician for five years - not waving my balls about, just saying that all the music theory I learned was less valuable than sitting down and trying to find something more satisfying.

4 Likes