🎵 HGATR: The First 100 🎵 THE RESULTS (Top 10 starts at post 1372)

Ill Communication is good place to go next.

Also Check Your Head and Hello Nasty for the Beastie Boys as jam band and eclectic genre hoppers respectively. All excellent albums.

I know it’s technically with stills Nash and young but literally all people know For What it’s Worth from Vietnam films

1 Like

Really surprised by this. Ghost Town alone should be enough to place them higher than Billy Joel and Queen!!

1 Like

Actually all I wanted was to work out how many I have left and there’s a list just upthread…

This is one for bands we tend to hate on

2 Likes

I gave them 18 - must have been a lot of no-shows on here!

I’m gonna start a thread

1 Like

My 20 pointers - thought they’d make top 10 on DiS :frowning:

1 Like

going to trawl through that thread, looks great fun

1 Like

Listening to to pimp a butterfly for the first time in a while.

Everytime I put it on I’m just absolutely blown away by it. The scope of it, the amount of ideas in it and how well it all holds together. Should be top 5 really.

Weeping at the sheer holistic achievement tbh

10 Likes

It’s crazy good isn’t it? I don’t listen to it often, mostly because I have young kids at home and I’m struggling hard enough not to swear in front of them as it is…

1 Like

Yeah probably listen to GKMC more often because I find it pretty much impossible to have butterfly on in the background. Just get completely sucked into it whenever I put it on. So, so good

2 Likes

Yeah I barely know Led Zep, Pink Floyd etc as my mum hates them, my dad is a jazz/classical buff and I was rejecting them as soon i was a teenager for not being indie enough. So I’ve never heard a full album by either of them, whereas for other people they could have been the entire soundtrack of their childhood

1 Like

Exactly the reason I never go back to it, just too much to take in and I’m constantly aware of not “appreciating” it enough. Go for section.80 or GKMC a lot more if I want a Kendrick hit (or just stick on Schoolboy instead)

It’s an odd one - I probably ‘enjoy’ GKMC more, but wouldn’t say it was the better album, if that makes sense.

To use a metaphor from above in the thread, TPAB is like a PTA film. I wouldn’t put There Will Be Blood on for an evening’s entertainment very often, but it’s clearly a staggering work.

It may be to do with the effort required. I can put GKMC on and get on with other stuff, whereas I need to focus on TPAB (as you said, actually)

2 Likes

Yeah I think TPAB is the better album and the more rewarding for an active listen (not that GKMC isn’t, their both top 10 of the decade) but it’s just too dense for a casual listen

Recently bought the vinyl editions of both albums (they were cheap for some reason) and listened to them both intensively for the first time in a while.

I had always thought TPAB was the classic. It is more coherent and perhaps more powerful and ‘important’ (whatever that means) but I actually ended up thinking that I had massively underrated GKMC. There are just so many good songs on it, so much range in terms of mood and style. It’s an astonishing record.

They are two absolute sky-scraping classics though - unquestionably two of the best 5 or 6 records of the last 20 years (and Damn is not far behind).

2 Likes

Time to start the top 20 I reckon

20. LCD SOUNDSYSTEM
(395pts, 3.92)

5 Likes