neil young or krist novoselic

Is Kim still in the Pixies in this scenario? If so Pixies

1 Like

Young’s got grit and bitterness but wouldn’t want to have angered Deal and Black after a skinful

Nebraska’s good. don’t care about the rest.

Bad Seeds have the numbers game over.

4 Likes

David Byrne could just run endlessly in circles until you collapsed in exhaustion and then jab you with a mic stand

1 Like

Cave is hard as fook. Probably had loads of proper teenage rucks with local bogans.

Definitely Kim. No need for physical contact. She’ll just stare until they cry.

3 Likes

Psycho killer!

1 Like

no.

3 Likes

To everyone voting Prince:
It’s not a “who can beat up the most women” contest.

I slyly reckon Radiohead might have a chance… Ed O’Brien’s almost 2 metres tall, and Colin and Phil look like they could handle themselves. Throw in Jonny and Thom as human shields/ambushing people, and they’d probably confuse the Bad Seeds a bit.

Bad seeds if we can pick any era (when Blixa was in the band)

2 Likes

If we could find a way to harness the energy generated by the handwringing about to ensue on this site, we could sole the world’s energy crisis in an afternoon.

2 Likes

some might argue they are sub chas & dave plodcore merchants, who took all the low hanging fruit only to let it rot

2 Likes

OH NO HE DIDNT
In all seriousness did Prince do that? Fuck man

Cobain and Grohl aren’t the fighty types but would take a lot of punches and stand their ground infinitely. Krist Novoselic is by far the toughest individual on the list though, young him is a real-life Wolverine.

Oh yikes :grimacing: didn’t know that

I reckon Thom could get quite bitey when cornered.