His Dark Materials

Teaser for the new series:

Really excited for this. Reread it after La Belle Sauvage and forgot just how brilliant the first book is. Rewatched The Golden Compass too which really really misses the mark.

Gonna read Subtle Knife soon.

2 Likes

Bit nervous about this tbh. Reckon I might be one of those book wankers that complains every time the show fails to capture the ~feel~ of the text

3 Likes

Can’t be worse than the movie adaptation.

I’m hype as hell, really hope they don’t shy away from the religious material this time

2 Likes

ooo yeah I started rereading these last year and need to finish that

my evening plans sorted :blush:

I probably won’t watch this tv adaptation unless people say its brilliant

1 Like

I hope BBC have invested enough money, and it’s not going to play out like a creaky period piece. I can totally imagine Doctor Who style effects and acting bollocksing this up.

The film just seemed like the screenwriter picked their 10 favourite bits from the book and put them in. No real feel of the developing of a story or characters. A TV series should have more time to let it breathe a bit.

Looks like it from the trailer, proper cbbc

still liked the film despite its badness

Please, please, please, please be good. It deserves a great adaptation. The casting seems pretty good (although i’m not sold on McAvoy) but the trailer does look quite BBC, but I’ll give it the benefit of the doubt for now, tis only a teaser.

Please, please be good.

2 Likes

I adore these books, really looking forward to this! The casting is very strong.

I never watched the film once I heard it was awful. The only part I’ve seen is the Iorek vs Iofur fight scene, looked that up on YouTube last time I re-read Northern Lights.

Need to do a re-read first.

I’ll probably watch it and enjoy it and it won’t be a patch on the books, which of course I only read a chapter of, before realising if i continued, I’d ruin any visual adaptations.

4 Likes

Belle Sauvage

  • Humdinger
  • Sumdinger
  • Bumdinger

0 voters

I liked it but didn’t love it. Still excited for the next one.

1 Like

Don’t worry I’m sure it’ll be fine. With a cast that good it would be difficult to fuck up too badly :grimacing: :crossed_fingers:

Slightly worried about accents but hopefully it’ll be ok. Looking forward to it.

I’m totally off watching adaptations of books I really love that are in this vein after Terry Pratchett’s ones got beasted. Gonna re read them though and cannot wait until my kids are old enough to enjoy them

1 Like

HDM is possibly my favourite thing in the world. Worked with a company during the development of a CCG based on it before Golden Compass :movie_camera: came along and buggered it all up. Still re-read it every 18 months or so.

6 Likes

Read these as a young teen, old teen and adult and they remain among my all-time faves. Not a sure daemons are ever gonna translate well to the screen but I hope to be proved wrong.

1 Like

I feel like BBC can throw all the money in the world at a drama production and it’ll still feel a bit creaky and cheap, unfortunately. Will still watch it though.

And I’m still massively fucked off by the end of La Belle Sauvage :frowning:

Love the books, will watch the series and would love it to be fantastic, but I’m preparing to be mildly disappointed.
Obviously the film is pretty bad, but i did think Nicole Kidman was a great choice for Mrs Coulter.

2 Likes

Love love love the books. Reread them recently and they’re still absolutely brilliant. Quite excited about the TV series, cast looks great apart from yer man Miranda, doesn’t really look the part. Dafne Keen as Lyra is inspired.