šŸ”„ Hot Freaks: the Guided By Voices Listening Club (Final results time! 40 album ranking list! Freedom! - post 2160)

First two tracks from Sandbox reminds me of Cheap Trick? That this followed Devil Between My Toes seems really strange. I definitely agree with the posts above about production being stuck in a middle ground and just not being great. Still - if this is one of the low points thatā€™s kind of a good sign.

1 Like

Yeah they were huge fans of cheap trick and toured with them in the 90s iirc from the latest book.

2 Likes

Sandbox score time

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters

Tracks (up to 3)

  • Lips of Steel
  • A Visit to the Creep Doctor
  • Everyday
  • Barricade
  • Get to Know the Ropes
  • Canā€™t Stop
  • The Drinking Jim Crow
  • Trap Soul Door
  • Common Rebels
  • Long Distance Man
  • I Certainly Hope Not
  • Adverse Wind
0 voters
1 Like

I hadnā€™t appreciated their European touring was such a rare event. I caught them at Leeds Festival in 2002.

Iā€™d heard Bob used to be a teacher and it cracked me up that he came onstage with a definite air of ā€œright class, weā€™ve got a lot to get through today.ā€

2 Likes

Mum thoughts

Listening to Devil between my toes, think the early tracks do sound like REM, but didnā€™t get that from the first album

Love the guitar on Hey hey spaceman

1 Like

Brutal numbers for Sandbox so far, yikes :face_with_diagonal_mouth:

Just being judged against how good we know they can be!

1 Like

Got my mental order wrong and thought weā€™d got into the 90s. Instead we have Self-Inflicted Aerial Nostalgia

2 Likes

Realised I read this as aural and not aerial for years. That is my only comment thus far. Off this week so may try and catch up if I get a minute

2 Likes

Hadnā€™t realised that the whole run of Devil to Propellor was mostly recorded in the same place - 8-track studio by a guy called Steve Wilbur

Some tracks here and there are obviously recorded differently, but still surprises me the wild variations in quality/volume/clarity across those albums even with that consistent recording studio

Been looking forward to revisiting this one, itā€™s been a while since I last heard it :+1:

Here are the writeups for Self-Inflicted Ariel Nostalgia at the An Earful 'O Wax and The Constant Bleeder fanblogs.

I think that studio might be where Bob gained his ā€˜Fading Captainā€™ nickname from originally i.e. he was the only one able to master the rickety studio technology to properly fade out the end of some of the songs where required.

2 Likes

Explains a lot about fidelity issues then

Comments on assorted songs from Self-Inflicted Aerial Nostalgia:

The Future Is In Eggs: love the drums & ominous feel at the start of this. Mumbled vocals from Bob, he really doesnā€™t care for eggs very much! I like the song, but it feels like an odd choice to kick off the album? But itā€™s nice to be back in Weirdsville.

Paper Girl: hahaha this just randomly starts off with a distorted blast of one of the Devil instrumentals, wtf? And then even more randomly morphs into a pretty acoustic ditty. ā€œā€¦the paper girlā€™s gonna blow awayā€, very sweet.

Navigating Flood Regions: yeah this is fucking great, a clear album highlight. Bob obviously loved this one because he resurrected it during the farewell tour in 2004. Great riff running all the way through the song, and very Lennon-ish catchy vocals too. The best tune from the pre-Propeller era?

Chief Barrel Belly: more Lennon vocals, but a bit unhinged this time. The guitars sound a bit grungy on this. A very powerful, propulsive song. Another highlight for me.

Dying To Try This: a lo-fi acoustic interlude, nice but nothing special. Another song where it sounds like Bob is trying to imitate somebody else vocally, but I canā€™t work out who?

Liarā€™s Tale: really beautiful tremolo guitar on this one, plus gorgeous longing vocals from Bob, ā€œlet me tell you a story, about the way she wasā€. Quite a unique-sounding song in the GBV cannon, just lovely really.

Gonna have some lunch, then come back with my overall thoughts on the album a bit later :+1:

3 Likes

Current lineup played it for a while as well. Had sadly dropped it by the time they came to London.

Think theyā€™ve played Liars Tale in their current incarnation as well

Good ones start soon!

Funny that this one comes before Same Place, as I think itā€™s more coherent and consistent overall again. Theyā€™re jumping all over the place over these first 4 main albums

1 Like

Think the best songs on this album are really great, but itā€™s quite up and down/patchy. Find this one less consistent than Devil which others might disagree with. Thereā€™s nothing bad on here but a few tracks are a little bit boring, whereas I find the weird instrumentals on Devil quite atmospheric and interesting. Better than Sandbox though definitely.

Best songs: Navigating Flood Regions, Trampoline, Radio Show

The GBV podcast that guy did where he reviewed every album was called Self Inflicted Aural Nostalgia which was a very clever name

2 Likes