šŸ”„ Hot Freaks: the Guided By Voices Listening Club (Final results time! 40 album ranking list! Freedom! - post 2160)

And heyyy letā€™s throw the great party
Today, for the rest of our lives
The funā€™s just about to get started
So throw the switch, itā€™s rock n roll time

Might be my favourite section of music ever

3 Likes

Who the fuck let them get a violin involved, so fucking good

1 Like

Demos: I played violin on ā€œBlimps Go 90,ā€ although not very well. When we recorded Propeller, I brought a violin to the studio and Bob said, ā€œWhat the hell, letā€™s give it a try.ā€ Itā€™s on ā€œOver The Neptune/Mesh Gear Foxā€ and ā€œWeedking.ā€ Itā€™s low in the mix with tons of effects. So we tried it again on ā€œBlimpsā€ but we didnā€™t have capabilities for mass effects on it. We also would use trash cans, amp drops, and anything else we could find to utilize as an instrument. I think it shows the unfettered creativity, independence, and disregard for industry norms that we had at that time and you can feel it on the record.

3 Likes

From an article about Alien Lanes so Iā€™ll try to remember to post the rest in a few weeks!

2 Likes

Back to Saturn X ranking

Damn Good Mr Jam (ā€œanything for freeā€) > Sopor Joe > Chicken Blows > Back to Saturn X > Broken Horse (early version of Tractor Rape Chain? Need to track it down) > Fantasy Creeps > Weird version of Buzzards > Mr Japan (ā€œtime of our livesā€)

1 Like

Well, this is quite the step up in quality :sunglasses:

3 Likes

The ending of Ergo Space Pig is almost Stones-y!

ā€œMetal Mothersā€ has a kinda mutant Oasis vibe to it, doesnā€™t it? One of my faves on the album, so addictive.

1 Like

Iā€™m being completely serious when I say that there is some sort of Hollywood movie waiting to be made about this period in the bands history*

Pretty much everybody bar his bandmates were telling Bob he was wasting his fucking time. Bobā€™s then-wife reportedly thought his music was absolutely awful, his Dad was annoyed Bob hadnā€™t developed his sporting prowess instead. Interest in the band was still pretty much zero, to the extent that Bob glumly decided to prioritise his teaching career and mothball the band as a going concern. Propeller was very much intended as the definitive final statement from the band.

What happened next is absolutely extraordinary. Just think of all the hundreds, even thousands, of songs which wouldā€™ve remained unwritten if Propeller hadnā€™t eventually found its way into the right hands.

The moral of the story: never, ever, ever give up on chasing your dreams.

*who on earth would get to play Bob in ā€œGBV: The Motion Pictureā€???

7 Likes

Paddy Considine!

3 Likes

I do this with album colors too, thought I was weird , I might still be but good to know other weird people too. Itā€™s one of the reasons I always like a first listen of an album to be with physical media instead of streaming , so I have the cover in hand and make that association.

I also have to have the album art for our band before finalizing the track list , so that I pick the songs which fit with the album color scheme!

2 Likes

Not sure what more can be said about Propeller, other than to say that it represents the first stone-cold classic from the band and heralded the start of their imperial phase :star_struck:

The easiest update to my personal GBV leaderboard to date:

  1. Propeller
  2. Self Inflicted Aerial Nostalgia
  3. Same Place the Fly Got Smashed
  4. Devil Between My Toes
  5. Forever Since Breakfast
  6. Sandbox
1 Like

WHERE ARE THE POLLS?

2 Likes

Full versions of all the songs that appear in Back to Saturn X Radio Report (Back to Saturn X was another abandoned album apparently)

3 Likes

Disappointed by the amount of CHAT this week. Even if all youā€™re saying is ā€œthis track is a fucking belterā€ itā€™s appreciated! Grumble grumble

Iā€™ll probably come in with some late opinions over the week, havenā€™t had much time to dive back into it this time

I listened to it once while getting very rained on and didnā€™t really take it in, will do so again this afternoon (without the rain).

1 Like

POLLS for PROPELLER

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
  • Over the Neptune / Mesh Gear Fox
  • Weedking
  • Particular Damaged
  • Quality of Armor
  • Metal Mothers
  • Lethargy
  • Unleashed! The Large-Hearted Boy
  • Red Gas Circle
  • Exit Flagger
  • 14 Cheerleader Coldfront
  • Back to Saturn X Radio Report
  • Ergo Space Pig
  • Circus World
  • Some Drilling Implied
  • On the Tundra
0 voters

Only got round to doing my Propeller re-listen today (but I know it well obviously)

I forgot about big rawk guitar solo in Circus World, kinda want to know who played it

1 Like

Over the Neptune, Weedking and Quality of Armor are all superb so those

Red Gas Circle is really underrated though imo

And 14 Cheerleader Coldfront being the first Tobin lead vocal

1 Like

Basic take is it starts incredibly, but it does tail off a bit at the end. Totally understand why people would have it as a masterpiece, but I think for me itā€™s sometimes overshadowed by what came after

whereas the good earlier albums get a boost from being compared to soemthing like Sandbox or the blandness of Forever Since Breakfast