šŸ”„ Hot Freaks: the Guided By Voices Listening Club (Final results time! 40 album ranking list! Freedom! - post 2160)

Well, old me tried and didnā€™t really get captured by any more recent albums! Iā€™ve got opinions like jill hives is a good song, glad girls is annoying, etc etc. to revisit tooā€¦ And Iā€™m sure Iā€™ve listened to and liked at least 3/4 of post-reunion albums, but never more than twice. Letā€™s hope it changes this time!

1 Like

Huge gap between the top three and the bottom five on that list right now, with Vampire sandwiched almost exactly in the middle.

Was originally some sort of fanclub-only release but got reissued later with some extra tracks. Not sure it counts as a proper ā€˜studio albumā€™ so donā€™t know whether weā€™re including it here or not?

1 Like

I like it a lot, so yes!

But after UTBUTS, want to keep the classic run intact

1 Like

Just realised I havenā€™t really heard much from Tonics for some reason. Iā€™ve definitely heard ā€œDayton, Ohioā€ and one or two others on there, but thatā€™s it I reckon.

Looking forward to checking it out now :sunglasses:

1 Like

Dayton is a top 5 GBV track for me

2 Likes

Think Iā€™ve only heard it once and that was few years ago now

Oh, last.fm tells me iā€™ve listened to it twice (2017 and 2019)

Donā€™t remember much from it beyond a couple of tracks that have popped up elsewhere

After the two beefed up Alien Lanes tracks, the rest of the Tigerbomb EP isnā€™t very good tbhā€¦aside from this absolutely glorious Tobin song. Summer pop bliss.

1 Like

Fun fact: Doug Gillard makes his first appearance on the Tigerbomb EP, two years before he joined the band! He co-wrote / plays on one song!

And itā€™s surprisingly shit!

2 Likes

Quite a few of the EPs around this time are very hit & miss, I reckon. Usually one absolute gem on each, but not a whole lot else bar one or two exceptions.

1 Like

Do we reckon theyā€™ll release 1,2 or more by the time weā€™re done?

Given how good the albums were I always expected the EPs to be all killer no filler but turns out itā€™s where all the rejects went (with one or two bangers to make it worth putting out)

2 Likes

To be fair to Doug itā€™s entirely Bobā€™s fault that this is bad

getting my last listen in before album changeover

1 Like

I only noticed that Bee Thousand ended up with a 9.89 rating :heart_eyes:

Pretty sure that wonā€™t be bettered, weā€™ll see.

1 Like

the votes are open!

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters

giving 5 options this time since thereā€™s so many tracks (shoulda done 5 for B1000 tbh)

  • A Salty Salute
  • Evil Speakers
  • Watch Me Jumpstart
  • Theyā€™re Not Witches
  • As We Go Up, We Go Down
  • (I Wanna Be A) Dumbcharger
  • Game Of Pricks
  • The Ugly Vision
  • A Good Flying Bird
  • Cigarette Tricks
  • Pimple Zoo
  • Big Chief Chinese Restaurant
  • Closer You Are
  • Auditorium
  • Motor Away
  • Hit
  • My Valuable Hunting Knife
  • Gold Hick
  • King And Caroline
  • Striped White Jets
  • Ex-Supermodel
  • Blimps Go 90
  • Straw Dogs
  • Chicken Blows
  • Little Whirl
  • My Cool Son
  • Always Crush Me
  • Alright
0 voters

@XenoPariah King and Caroline knocking right on the door of my top 5 here tbh

2 Likes

Blimps go 90 has become a favourite over the last week for me.

1 Like

yeah that and K&C are a toss up for my 5th (Hunting Knife should be there, but always nice to rep a less known track rather than just the ā€œhitsā€)