šŸ”„ Hot Freaks: the Guided By Voices Listening Club (Final results time! 40 album ranking list! Freedom! - post 2160)

As myyada said itā€™s largely down to Pollardā€™s voice on the record. It absolutely has some of my favourite stuff on there, but itā€™s not entirely surprising to me he ā€˜endedā€™ GBV soon after.

He must have been completely exhausted after the previous decade

1 Like

Love ā€œIā€™ll Replace You With Machinesā€, even (especially?) the guy trying to unblock a toilet in the background

4 Likes

Worth remembering the glut of other stuff he was putting out around this time as well i.e. multiple solo records, collabs, plus heā€™d just started up the Circus Devils project. No idea where he found all the energy (or inspiration).

2 Likes

Hi allā€¦ Iā€™ve launched my GBV music league if anyone wants to get involved:
https://app.musicleague.com/l/c39fc65027454ec3a06fb30164abc236/

2 Likes

May have to sit this out for a week or two, sorry @JaguarPirate

Got lots going on at home right now :roll_eyes:

Hope everything works out! See you back when you can make it

1 Like

Going to dig my CDs of this run out at my parentsā€™ gaff at the weekend. Might even get shitfaced in my old room there and listen to them all in a row.

This post paid for by PROF$.

3 Likes

hope everyone had time to listen to EG and get ready to VOTE

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
  • My Kind of Soldier
  • My Son, My Secretary And My Country
  • Iā€™ll Replace You With Machines
  • She Goes Off At Night
  • Beat Your Wings
  • Useless Inventions
  • Dirty Water
  • The Best Of Jill Hives
  • Dead Cloud
  • Mix Up The Satellite
  • The Main Street Wizards
  • A Trophy Mule In Particular
  • Apology In Advance
  • Secret Star
  • Of Mites And Men
0 voters

Best of Jill Hives is one of their all timers, the way Bob writes about depression can really cut like a knife

2 Likes

so on relisten i like his a little less than I thought I did. Donā€™t think itā€™s actually any worse, but Iā€™ve realised I like the albums around it (especially UT&C) more than I thought I did, so EG doesnā€™t stand out as much

that said, still just really enjoy the poppy-prog thing theyā€™re going for here and some of the production flourishes with the strings and synths popping up - but more organically than on DTC. Really consistent, no bad tracks, some amazing instrumental sections and Bob pens a handful of pop beauties. My Kind of Soldier and Best of Jill Hives are chiming brilliance, and Useless Inventions gets overlooked by as I-C said itā€™s sort of a standout anthem. The bombast of Replace You With Machines is great fun, and then the whole last third is some of my fav stuff, big sweeping epic songs mixed in with weird little tempo changes and memorable lyrics. Main Street Wizards is in contention for most underrated GBV song ever, and Secret Star is as grandiose as anything they managed before or since - would be nearly as good of a ā€œfinal GBVā€ song as Huffman was

a very good 8, probably still challenging for my top 5

1 Like

Just never can get into this one. My introduction to GBV was Letā€™s Go Eat The Factoryā€¦I liked that and Class clown , so next step was to listen to the classics , so picked.up B1000 and Alien Lanes. Loves both those too. So then when looking where to go next , I liked the name and cover of Earthquake Glue. It was the first GBV album I was disappointed with.

So gave it another go this week , hoping maybe it was just because I listened to it straight after those other great albums, but now still havenā€™t really like warmed to it. Just doesnā€™t have the hooks for me and I donā€™t care for the Psych P as much as Bobā€™s other 3.

Someone above mentioned how the current lines ups albums seem to use this as a template , which is true and maybe why I havenā€™t been a big fan of the recent stuff either.

A lot of shite on the horizon

time to head into the actual honestly final act of GBV with HALF SMILES OF THE DECOMPOSED

3 Likes

said this for about 5 albums, but I think this might actually be their best opening track of all

2 Likes

ā€œOver the Neptuneā€¦ā€ just pips it for me, but itā€™s a classic for sure

1 Like

Yeah, thatā€™s what I settled on.

1 Like

YAS M8!

1 Like

I guess Neptune just jumps straight into the ā€œbest song listā€ so I tend to discount it from ā€œbest openersā€ cos brains are smart :smiley:

1 Like

A MIRACLE CURE FOR MY SORROWS

1 Like

Every beam I choose is shining alone on you is the most romantic lyric of all time donā€™t @ me

1 Like