šŸ”„ Hot Freaks: the Guided By Voices Listening Club (Final results time! 40 album ranking list! Freedom! - post 2160)

Iā€™m insisting on listening to the CD rather than streaming it at work so tonight or tomorrow :smiley:

1 Like

and with all that said, with barely a second to catch our breath ā€¦ itā€™s reunion time with LETā€™S GO EAT THE FACTORY

3 Likes

Donā€™t call OSHA!

3 Likes

what a comeback song, when I heard this on P4K it made my year basically. Played it pretty relentlessly

all-time Bob song title also

1 Like

BEYOND THE VULNERABILITIES
AND NUCLEAR FACILITIES

That sound when Greg hits the floor!! :laughing:

2 Likes

Here is the writeup for Letā€™s Go Eat The Factory over at the Earful 'O Wax fan blog.

(Looks like we have finally caught up with the Constant Bleeder page, I think he adds like a release per month and heā€™s reached as far as late 2005 to this point).

2 Likes

Hmm, Earful man doesnā€™t dig it much does he? I started reading the Pitchfork review earlier too, but it was too annoying to finish. Suffice to say they didnā€™t like it much either.

My thoughts - before a proper listen and reappraisal - is that the critics place too much value on the need for cohesiveness, really. If it wasnā€™t being compared to Bee Thousand and had decent artwork, I reckon theyā€™d dig it more. Also reckon thereā€™s more to it than was immediately noticeable at the time. The singles, for example, hold up very well - even if Demos canā€™t get through a live TV performance without falling over.

3 Likes

Perfect relaxing work music ā€¦

Yeah Iā€™ve liked reading both blogs but I very rarely actually agree with Earfulā€™s scores - God Loves Us a one?? Madness

1 Like

as the waves crash around youuuu

Ocean Waves GIF

1 Like

Soā€¦I donā€™t really know what to say about this album, other than I REALLY donā€™t like it. Itā€™s easily my least fave GBV album post-Sandbox.

Factory came out years before I belatedly discovered the band, but I can only think it mustā€™ve been a huge anti-climax to the fans at the time. A real wet fart of a comeback album :grimacing:

I remember one of the blog guys saying that Sandbox is missing any personality, and I think the same applies here as well to be honest. It just all feels a bit half-hearted to these ears, the songs just arenā€™t there which is something you can hardly ever say about anything with Bobā€™s name attached to it.

The highlights:

  • A couple of all-timers in ā€œLaundry & Lasersā€ and of course ā€œThe Unsinkable Fats Dominoā€
  • I guess ā€œThe Headā€ and ā€œImperial Racehorsingā€ are pretty good
  • The Tobes songs are solid

ā€¦and that is it. Nothing else really stands out to me :person_shrugging:

Iā€™m listening to it now as I type having not heard it for a few years. REALLY enjoying it to be honest.

3 Likes

I mean, even the album artwork is half-assed.

Bob, what the hell man???

guided_by_voices_lets_go_eat_the_factory_large

2 Likes

Sorry, from a real-time fan - wrong!

Think some of the solo Bob stuff between Half Smiles and this was better, but it all blurred together - this had the hiss and weirdness and Tobin that his albums had been missing

Feels more like a throwback to Fly or VoT than anything else imho, for better and worse

2 Likes

Some was definitely it being ā€œnewā€ though - not sure how Iā€™d view it if it was the 3rd or 5th reunion album instead of the one that kicked things off again

I just noticed that the Earful dude described Factory as

ā€¦which kinda sums it up for me too :person_shrugging:

funny cos Iā€™d say personality is what it had the most of :smiley: more than tunes or cohesion or any of those other pesky positive things lol

1 Like

True, but on VoT, Fly etc. the hiss and weirdness framed some truly fantastic songwriting. Iā€™m just not hearing that at all on this album tbh.

tbf this is a lot of defending for an album im gonna give a high 6, decent 7 to

its good and stands out over a lot of other reunion stuff imho, but it is plenty flawed too

2 Likes