so yeah, Class Clown is good - shock to everyone! Less unique/memorable than Factory and just not quite as good a set of songs as Bears imho, so thatās probably why it got lost in the shuffle for me. Plus years of not having easy access to a way to listen to it, canāt have helped
Despite shitting on Tobinās songs this time round it turns out my two favs are Forever Until it Breaks and All of This Will Go, canāt trust a thing I say. Both lovely moments of pure Toby sweetness but build to something a bit bigger, feel almost grand and stately by his standards. Really into his faux-orchestra sound on Forever, its kitsch but fun
Title track is great but Iāll always prefer the Suitcase version so just sounds a bit off to me - still a classic anyway. Couple of Bob mini-masterpieces in Chain to the Moon and Fly Baby, though Chain I especially wish was longer! If we just got another verse and chorus it would be my fav track on here I think
Keep It In Motion is a total earworm, love the transition into the psych sprawl of Tysonās High School, and Billy Wire completes a strong heavier middle section. BW is a proper leg-kicker mic-twirler. Surprised that No Transmission hasnāt made anyoneās top 3 yet, think itās just behind BW as my fav pure rock track - great closer. Might throw it a vote actually, BW is already romping ahead as it is
think thereās a few too many blink-and-theyāre-gone tracks that donāt leave much of an impression, always feels weird this is a 20+ song album as I couldnāt name half of them. Thereās literally not a bad track on here, but more mid-tier stuff than the other reunions. Again - Factory peaks highest and lowest, Bears is a similar vibe to this but just all a little more memorable or heavier etc.
a 7 feels a bit light but maybe fair. Gonna be interesting when we get into the later albums, do I start dropping down to actual bad scores, or will GBV basically always be 6/10 albums even at their least inspiring? some of these current scores might seem a bit off if iām giving much worse albums only one point less!
but yeah, a very good original reunion trio of albums that show off lots of the diff sides of GBV. If theyād called it quits here I think everyone would have been happy to have these 60 new tracks even if they didnāt scale the old peaks