šŸ”„ Hot Freaks: the Guided By Voices Listening Club (Final results time! 40 album ranking list! Freedom! - post 2160)

If you did want to do it ā€œrightā€ hereā€™s the order itā€™s supposed to be - actually just moving Zero Elasticity (/Record Level Love) up to track 9 shifts everything else into the correct place too

Titles will still be fucked tho

2 Likes

Cheers, Iā€™ll probably just live with it until my CD arrives and then get confused all over again! :grinning:

1 Like

Ahaha. Fire didnā€™t have great QC around then. Fairly sure the inner to English Little League is meant to have print/lyrics on both sides but one side is completely blank. Iā€™ve got a Mission of Burma record from that time without a centre label. Wouldnā€™t surprise me that the fact Class Clown isnā€™t on streaming is just cos they forgot about renewing it.

2 Likes

I only have the CD but they only include lyrics to one track - ā€˜Obligitory Indecipherable Lyric to Burning Glassā€™ (pretty sure thatā€™s by design!)

Oh right. Just looked on Discogs and seems to be the same too. It feels really weird though, to have a higher quality inner specific to the record and just print one side of it.

That is odd, on the CD itā€™s just printed in the gatefold so it looks fine and then the art from the back cover but without the text is on the opposite part of the gatefold, maybe that was supposed to be on the other side of the vinyl inner

So this is pretty great! I did listen to ELL twice and it left no impression, but this is fun, varied, full of life. Maybe itā€™s just because itā€™s brand new to my ears, but honestly putting this up in the same level as Class Clown and Bears for Lunch, a few standouts and then lots of little earworms scattered through that catch you at different times. Got great production too, punchy but messy, some fun lofi experiments but nothing too unlistenable or equally nothing too shiny and clean

Feel like they nailed the song lengths too, a few get to stretch their legs but mostly all short enough to feel like ā€œclassicā€ GBV without being so short as to pass by without noticing (which I felt happened to some stuff on CC). We actually get more than one verse one chorus!

Littlest League and Until Next Time is a strong opener, fun little anthem and odd ballad with wonky piano segueing together perfectly. Very like Bob to introduce a lovely new riff in the last 10 seconds of a track :smiley:

Writerā€™s Bloc sounds like Boston Spaceships, I actually like this quite a bit. Good driving repetitive riff to it, has a bit of the caveman God Loves Us energy which Iā€™m so keen on. Child Activist isnā€™t much on its own, but fits well as the next track, giving us a heavier section. Then straight into Planet Score which is a perfect GBV reunion anthem really, could easily have slipped onto UTBUTS, with Bob in fine voice too

Fun messy psych guitars on Jupiter Spin, again Tobin pushing out of his more standard jangle sweetness ā€“ reminiscent of Spiderfighter on Factory maybe? Record Level Love is gorgeous too, such a sweet chorus.

Then I Am Columbus which with that monster bass, one of the best riffs theyā€™ve put to tape honestly. One of the more interest unique reunion tracks, couldnā€™t see them making this at any time in the past but it has the feel of something classic. Zero Elasticity is almost annoying but think it wins me around in the end, strutting 70s rawk

Shine into Vote for Me Dummy is the best pairing on here, and honestly maybe the best 1-2 in the entire reunion so far? Absolutely love Shine - Tobin channelling Moonflower Plastic in the best way, that lovely spacey outro solo, and then crashing straight into Vote for Me Dummy which is painfully catchy. ā€œLife will be a piece of caaaaakeā€ has been stuck in my head all week. Next Tobin track is grand too, more stately but still builds to vintage jangle fuzz

Then Alex and the Omegas obviously a great closer, foot stomping anthem

5 Likes

Not really any skippers compared to other recent albums, but Go Without Packing and A Bird with No Name come closest. Could bump them and get an even trimmer 35 min album, but really this feels pretty compact and well judged as is! Maybe my second fav discovery of the club so far, along with reassessing UT&C

2 Likes

My hot take for the day: Motivational Jumpsuit is better than either Half Smiles or Earthquake Glue.

3 Likes

Will Smith Reaction GIF

1 Like

anyone know why ELL is their 19th album on Wiki, but Motivational Jumpsuit is the 21st?

probably Tonics and Twisted Chasers being weird as usual

English Little League - every song is twice as long as it should be. Could basically leave it there tbh

really not that inspiring! the sound of a band running on fumes, weird they managed to make MJ so much livelier right after this

  • Xeno is fun, good chorus of Bobā€™s yelling away
  • She Talks in Rainbows is sweet, but donā€™t think it rises to the levels of his best on any other reunion albums. Maybe the production more than anything? Vocals feel very separate from the music
  • Trash Can Full of Nails is quite fun stop start stomp into jangly chorus, but could be half as long
  • Send to Celeste is big and sweeping, lovely romantic ballad. Sounds like something off Earthquake Glue or Half Smiles, but without some of the production flourishes or musical ā€¦ skill which I like so much from those projects. Would have benefitted from a bit more subtlety
  • Enjoy the music of The Quiet Game but not doing loads for me vocally which is odd for Tobin
  • Noble Insect is weirdly catchy, hypnotic. Good organ drone, pops up on a few songs as one of the few interesting touches production-wise
  • I actually like Sir Garlic Breath, but if any song should be a fun throwaway 30 second thing itā€™s this one.
  • Crybaby is just the rhythm of Letā€™s Go Vike set to worse music
  • Biographer Seahorse has good sprawl and drama to it similar to Send to Celeste, but Bob really needed another vocal take here, and doesnā€™t justify its length at all
  • Flunky Minnows is fun, best thing on here probably
  • No comment on the rest of the tracks, drops off hard. Glass in Foot has a weird fun riff and good drums I guess

wooft, rough. Think Send to Celeste and Flunky Minnows are all Iā€™d save from this, and doubt either would even make my top ā€¦ 20 reunion tracks.

2 Likes

Congrats ELL, could be the worst full GBV album yet! Only Sandbox is in contention, and Everyday, Trap Soul Door and Long Distance Man are comfortably better than anything on here

Time for the Jaggy P personal leaderboard, methinksā€¦

quite unsure of a lot of it but hereā€™s something! the whole 8-16 range could move about a lot

  1. Bee Thousand
  2. Under The Bushes Under The Stars
  3. Alien Lanes
  4. Half Smiles of the Decomposed
  5. Earthquake Glue
  6. Propeller
  7. Self-Inflicted Aerial Nostalgia
  8. The Bears for Lunch
  9. Universal Truths & Cycles
  10. Vampire on Titus
  11. Motivational Jumpsuit
  12. Mag Earwhig!
  13. Isolation Drills
  14. Do The Collapse
  15. Letā€™s Go Eat The Factory
  16. Class Clown Spots a UFO
  17. Devil Between My Toes
  18. Same Place the Fly Got Smashed
  19. Forever Since Breakfast
  20. Sandbox
  21. English Little League
1 Like

I let out more than one Ooff when reading that list lol

Fascinating how some of us hear completely different things on a handful of these albums. Thank you for sharing!

Updated personal leaderboard:

  1. Bee Thousand
  2. Under The Bushes Under The Stars
  3. Propeller
  4. Alien Lanes
  5. Isolation Drills
  6. The Bears for Lunch
  7. Class Clown Spots a UFO
  8. Universal Truths & Cycles
  9. Do The Collapse
  10. Vampire on Titus
  11. Mag Earwhig!
  12. Motivational Jumpsuit
  13. Half Smiles of the Decomposed
  14. Earthquake Glue
  15. Self Inflicted Aerial Nostalgia
  16. Same Place the Fly Got Smashed
  17. Devil Between My Toes
  18. English Little League
  19. Letā€™s Go Eat The Factory
  20. Forever Since Breakfast
  21. Sandbox

Iā€™m probably being a bit generous with my placement of Motivational Jumpsuit, but I ended up enjoying it quite a lot more than I expected to this past week.

1 Like

MOTIVATED to do some polls now for MJ

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
  • The Littlest League Possible
  • Until Next Time
  • Writersā€™ Bloc (Psycho All The Time)
  • Child Activist
  • Planet Score
  • Jupiter Spin
  • Save The Company
  • Go Without Packing
  • Record Level Love
  • I Am Columbus
  • Difficult Outburst And Breakthrough
  • Calling Up Washington
  • Zero Elasticity
  • A Bird With No Name
  • Shine (Tomahawk Breath)
  • Vote For Me Dummy
  • Some Things Are Big (And Some Things Are Small)
  • Bulletin Borders
  • Evangeline Dandelion
  • Alex And The Omegas
0 voters

hopefully we donā€™t get track vote confusion given the fuckery with the Spotify song names :smiley:

Twelve votes for nine different songs already :open_mouth: