It’s an obvious 5.
I actually hated his guts when I was a kid, around the time of Born In The USA. Thought he was a jingoistic dick (because I didn’t bother listening to the words) and all my friends’ mums fancied him. His look was the antithesis of everything I stood for.
When I was a bit older I listened to the big albums and liked them, but never really connected in the way I do with other artists.
Then in the last 10 years my other half took me to see him live and suddenly it all clicked into place and I really love him now.
I also admire him - his autobiography is hugely impressive. He admits he’s vain, and that showing off in front of people is his drug. But he also suffers terrible depression, which he describes in a way that imo was not designed to elicit sympathy. Not that this should matter because all my scores so far are dickishness-neutral.
PS I didn’t vote in the Girls Aloud poll because I don’t know enough of their material, but it would have been a 1 even before considering their racist assaults.