Yeah – totally remember this as well and how off it felt. Like long opinion pieces in broadsheet newspapers exploring rhyme structure and imploring people to look beyond the surface level violence to see the biting social commentary in his lyrics. Can’t possibly think why his lyrics was singled out for this type of treatment and literally no other rapper’s were.
In fairness to Eminem, remember him rubbishing any claims that he was the greatest rapper ever in interviews and constantly boosting Redman when he was asked the question, which was obviously both great and correct.