Conversely to this I recall the NME giving their debut album 10/10 which at that point I only think I’d seen them give one 10/10 before in my NME buying years (Godflesh - Streetcleaner). When that NME review cited the album as important a debut as the first Ramones album - I just went and bought it.
From there on in the whole scene for me began to break and when “Grunge” was in - I moved away slowly. For these kind of reasons I never listened to another Hole album in full, but with that real fire in the belly debut the NME weren’t far off with their rating and it’s a fantastic record.