Yeah I donāt think Iāve heard anything after Know Your Enemy tbh and people will probably now tell me that I should but I really canāt be bothered. Iāve given them a 4 cause Everything Must Go was one of the first albums I ever got really into, TIMTTMY has moments of absolute genius and Holy Bible is fucking great obv, plus pretty much all the singles before that are good. Agree about them live too, brilliant.
Definitely a band that got far more attention than they deserved due to tragic circumstances. Was listening to Nicky Wire on Adam Buxtonās podcast and he sounded bitter that theyāre not more respected and all I could think was āYou arrogant fuck, you never deserved to be as popular as you are, and youāre complaining you donāt get more reverence!?ā. So deluded.
Loved them when I was 16. Just when GT came out. They sent me a signed photo and white label unprompted just because I wrote to them. If they stopped after The Holy Bible, I think they would have been revered. Love everything until thatā¦just lost interest since then. 5 for early career. 3 overall
A band that Iāve gone from loving to having absolute apathy towards. Iāve never listened to anything post Everything Must Go, so my opinion is totally formed from the first four albums.
There was a real excitement about them initially, which came to a crescendo with the release of The Holy Bible. That really was a statement album, and I absolutely caned in it when it came out. Was fortunate enough to catch them at the Astoria touring it, in that little time-frame between Richey leaving rehab (he wasnāt with them at Reading that previous summer) and going missing. What a show. It was incendiary and exciting and fun.
I totally bought into EMG initially. Didnāt expect much from a post-Richey Manics, but felt it was solid. It was another Reading Festival show around that time though that I finally gave up on them. It was dull, and plodding. Iāve never really listened to them again. I did give The Holy Bible a spin a couple of years back and it had lost all its impact for me. Nothing about it excited me.
Iāve given them a 2 at the moment. But since writing this, that feels a little unfair as they obviously were a significant part of my listening history for a while. Might up it to a 3 because thereās nothing I actively dislike about them. I wouldnāt turn the radio off if they came on. I just would never choose to listen to them.
Going to have to ponder here. At their best an easy 5, but there is a fair amount of dreck as well. Not as simple as early stuff good, later bad because Futorology is one of the best things theyāve done. Wish theyād gone straight from This Is My Truth to Send Away The Tigers without those duff records in between. They deserve an extra point for dealing with awful circumstances with as much dignity as they could, and also for generally being a bit spiky and amusing. 3.5 rounded up to 4, I reckon.
A very important band for me growing up. The Holy Bible still sounds exhilarating (especially the US mix). I would give a 4.5 but since you canāt itās a 5.
Was never into the Manics as much as others. They were a big thing when I was at uni - thereād always be a really obvious fan of theirs (or six) at any given indie night. Loved some of their stuff; hated some of it.
Gone for 3/5 - would probably have gone 7/10 if this was food not bands.