REM have made some great records, but I do find the college rock run to be more than a little overrated. Maybe it’s just because the influence is so all-pervading but I can’t work out what people find to be so special about it.
Radiohead are my favourite band and have made at least three of my favourite records by anyone. Four if you count the “ignore the tracks they put on the album and out different tracks on it instead” version of KotL. Of the other albums, three are still great, one is very good and the other two are Pablo honey and the Bends.