📺 How Good Was it Really?: Red Dwarf 📺

Hello and welcome to HGWIR SCI-FI WEEK!

How’s that comedy table looking?

Rank Show Rating
1 I’m Alan Partridge 4.79
2 The Thick of It 4.69
3 Nathan for You 4.13
4 Seinfeld 4.09
5 The Office UK 4.07
6 Futurama 3.97
7 Fawlty Towers 3.89
8 Knowing Me, Knowing You 3.84
9 Mid Morning Matters 3.8
10 Limmy’s Show 3.77
11 The League of Gentlemen 3.64
12 Veep 3.63
13 The Office US 3.48
14 Monty Python’s Flying Circus 3.22
15 Malcolm in the Middle 3.18
16 Psychoville 3.01
17 Friends 2.98
18 Mr. Bean 2.94
19 Only Fools and Horses 2.94
20 The Mighty Boosh 2.73
21 Rock Profile 2.67
22 Goodnight Sweetheart 2.11
23 Noel Fielding’s Luxury Comedy 1.63
R Miranda 1.49
R Little Britain 1.27
R Come Fly With Me 1.13

So, Red Dwarf.

(yeah I know Red Dwarf hasn’t technically ended but really it is has, hasn’t it. So we’re doing it)

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

0 voters

Best main guy

  • Kryten
  • Lister
  • Rimmer
  • The Cat

0 voters

Does anything after VI exist?

  • Yes
  • VII? It ended with VI mate

0 voters

I liked it at the time but feel if I rewatched it I wouldn’t so much, maybe

Going to think about this a bit.

1 Like

Best Holly?

  • Man Holly
  • Woman Holly

0 voters

Best Kochanski

  • Clare Grogan
  • the other one

0 voters

Best theme tune ever?

  • yes
  • yes!

0 voters

have memories of being really young and me my dad and little sister dancing round the living room every time an episode finished :’)

1 Like

Really not my cup of tea. Want to like it, but don’t really :frowning:


This series (and the brilliant books) probably defined my sense of humour as a young teen more than anything else.


Think I’m in the minority of preferring the first series - the episodes in which the antagonism between Rimmer and Lister takes centre stage are the highlights.

So much gold before it finished on a cliffhanger and never came back at the end of S6 though. Of the later episodes, Quarantine and the Inquisitor stand out.

Was going to give a high 4 - but fuck it, other than Hitchhiker’s Guide it is unassailed in the world of sci-fi comedy. Let’s go 5.


Watched it, liked it.

Rewatched it some years later and found it complete rubbish.

Really really really bad.

Tried to like it at the time, but it just wasnt very good.

And its aged badly.



Sort of watched bits of it. My sister had some tapes and I remember going on the red dwarf website. It seemed like it was enjoyed mainly by friends older nerd brothers.

But sir! Space directive 436b? It is forbidden to catapault bananas with a caterpillar on your arse? HAHAHAHAHA


smeeeeg heeed!


Yow! Im.the cat! Yow! Check out my suit!


Reminds me of Friday nights when I was a kid. Delicious.

1 Like

4/5 some great moments but hasn’t reaalynstoodnthe test of time.

Ive got one for rimmer and lister too but ill save them for later