Is The Black Parade better than American Idiot?

I’ve never listened to it.

  • Yes
  • No
0 voters

No chance

5 Likes

All worse than this

Probably. I’ve never listened to it, mind.

2 Likes

I loved American idiot when it came out and liked the black parade when it came out. Their previous album was better imo

2 Likes

Just seen that Teenagers is on it. Which means I don’t even need to listen to it to know that American Idiot is better, as American Idiot has no bad songs on it.

4 Likes

No but it’s more fun to get smashed and belt out

Yes American Idiot is shite.

9 Likes

Yes.
Haven’t listened to either.

The Black Parade is where MCR fell off, man

4 Likes

I GOT A ROCK N ROLL HOUSE
I GOT A ROCK N ROLL CAR!
I PLAY THE SHIT OUT THE DRUMS
AND I CAN PLAY THE GUITAR

3 Likes

Hate posting stuff on the Music board because it’s indexed unlike the other boards. Might as well just be sat here naked on a plinth in the middle of Trafalgar Square.

5 Likes

American Idiot is excellent

Yeah, Fuck You Bush!

4 Likes

Haven’t heard either one, but both bands have good stuff before those so don’t care.

1 Like

It’s this in an album

1 Like

Dookie is the only Green Day album I own but I don’t think I’d bother to own American Idiot.

I don’t own any My Chemical Romance but if I saw The Black Parade in a chazza I might pick it up.

Gerard Way is a GBOL and I like his comics writing.
Billy Joe Armstrong is also a GBOL. I don’t think he writes comics, but I’d read one if he did.

What was the question again?

3 Likes

Think you meant to say

“American Idiot is where Green Day fell off, man”

Easy mistake to make

It’s their best album!

Nah, American Idiot is where Green Day briefly climbed back on again. Warning is where Green Day fell off

4 Likes