Let's make a Metallica Best Of

#1

studio albums only
12 songs
12 votes
go!

  • KEM - Whiplash
  • KEM - Jump In The Fire
  • KEM - Seek & Destroy
  • RTL - Fight Fire With Fire
  • RTL - Ride The Lightning
  • RTL - For Whom The Bell Tolls
  • RTL - Fade to Black
  • RTL - Trapped Under Ice
  • RTL - Escape
  • RTL - Creeping Death
  • RTL - The Call of Ktulu
  • MOP - Battery
  • MOP - Master of Puppets
  • MOP - The Thing That Should Not Be
  • MOP - Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
  • MOP - Disposable Heroes
  • MOP - Leper Messiah
  • MOP - Orion
  • MOP - Damage, Inc.
  • AJFA - Blackened
  • AJFA - …And Justice For All
  • AJFA - Eye of the Beholder
  • AJFA - One
  • AJFA - Harvester of Sorrow
  • AJFA - The Frayed Ends of Sanity
  • AJFA - To Live Is To Die
  • AJFA - Dyers Eve
  • TBA - Enter Sandman
  • TBA - Sad But True
  • TBA - Holier Than Thou
  • TBA - The Unforgiven
  • TBA - Wherever I May Roam
  • TBA - Through The Never
  • TBA - Nothing Else Matters
  • TBA - Of Wolf And Man
  • TBA - The God That Failed
  • L - Until It Sleeps
  • L - Hero of the Day
  • L - Mama Said
  • RL - Fuel
  • RL - The Memory Remains
  • RL - The Unforgiven II
  • SA - Frantic
  • SA - St Anger
  • DM - The Day That Never Comes
  • DM - Cyanide
  • DM - The Judas Kiss
  • HTSD - Hardwired
  • HTSD - Atlas, Rise!
  • HTSD - Moth Into Flame

0 voters

fuck i typed out their whole discog but had to cut it down to 50 because of the RULES.

#2
#3

I got confused and thought Moth To Flame was Spit Out The Bone, which is aces. Not that arsed about MTF tbh

#4

surprisingly low turnout for sad but true so far

#5

Kill E Mall

#6

whoops :smiley: i originally put ‘sade but true’ as well

#7

Why can’t I vote for the table song?

#8

For whom the bell tolls x12

#9

It’s missing 3 of the best 4 on Reload! (Fixxxer, Carpe Diem Baby, Low Man’s Lyric). But Hero of the Day is definitely the best one on Load.

#10

not listened to it in years so I dunno if it holds up, but ronnie was always my favourite on load

#11

had to get rid of 57 tracks from their discog so had to fall back on singles

#12

maybe because YOU ARE THE TABLE!!!

#13

https://vocaroo.com/i/s05YZaL3Hx3f

#14

I Disappear
One of the tracks from S&M because that’s alright.
The one with the fucking shit drums
Tears of Dave Mustaine
That Misfits cover

#15

i actually really like this song

hey hey heyyyyyaeeeeeahhhhhh

#16

Same. Never taken to Metallica at all out of the big four, find them absolute yawnfest but that one is a banger. Love the opening guitar squeal.

#17

Is it wrong to say there are only 2 Metallica songs I would chose to listen to, and one is St Anger

#18

Cause it’s terrible?

#19

It’s no fave of mine but it’s not bad is it?

#20

It’d say it’s where Metallica lost me. Rubbish as enter sandman is, it’s not this bland.
It’s so awful, a rock ballad in the worst way. It may as well be Extreme.
(I really don’t like it btw)