listen to a Classic DiS Album for the first time

remember something like this being a really fun thread on the old boards, and been thinking about resurrecting it for years. Well, today is the day!

basically pick any album that feels like a DiS-approved classic that you haven’t heard before, give it a spin, and post your thoughts here. If other people want to try the same album they can and have a chat about it, or we all just pick random ones and go off on our own paths. No Minimal rules!

7 Likes

In case it’s useful to find records

Recommended albums on our old site // Drowned In Sound

Our album of the year lists compiled (should probably do our own page like this on the new website): https://www.albumoftheyear.org/publication/3-drowned-in-sound/lists/

3 Likes

I’m going to kick things off with Belle and Sebastian and If You’re Feeling Sinister. I’ve always liked Arab Strap but for some reason never explored beyond that, and chatting to people about their recent Glasgow shows just got me thinking again. Local legends too, so some bonus box-ticking points for me there

1 Like

19 Likes

Fuck the haters, this is a wonderful album :heart:

(As is Tigermilk if you haven’t listened to that either)

16 Likes

I probably should listen to Neutral Milk Hotel, but if I’m honest I really can’t be arsed.

3 Likes

Top 20 all timer for me. Hope you enjoy

1 Like

This is the opposite of what this thread is about.

Listen to it, hate it, and share your vitriol here!

2 Likes

pity JaggyP didn’t go for one of the two good Belle & Sebastian albums :frowning:

Someone tell me an album to listen to please

Mclusky do dallas?

2 Likes

Wait for Me by the Pigeon Detectives :ogre:

Okay!

2 Likes

Bugs Bunny Says NO

7 Likes

here’s the full list of best albums as voted by the boards

Summary
ALBUM ARTIST POINTS VOTES TOTAL
Ys Joanna Newsom 28 6 168
Spiderland Slint 18 7 126
The Midnight Organ Fight Frightened Rabbit 12 7 84
OK Computer Radiohead 12 6 72
Kid A Radiohead 11 6 66
The Meadowlands The Wrens 16 4 64
In The Aeroplane Over The Sea Neutral Milk Hotel 11 5 55
Lift Yr Skinny Fists… Godspeed You! Black Emperor 11 5 55
Madvillainy Madvillain 11 4 44
Oil Of Every Pearl’s Un-Insides SOPHIE 22 2 44
Didn’t It Rain Songs: Ohia 21 2 42
Weezer (Blue Album) Weezer 8 5 40
Hounds Of Love Kate Bush 13 3 39
The Magnolia Electric Co. Songs: Ohia 9 4 36
Disintegration The Cure 9 4 36
good kid, m.A.A.d city Kendrick Lamar 8 4 32
Born To Run Bruce Springsteen 8 4 32
The Argument Fugazi 10 3 30
Blonde Frank Ocean 7 4 28
The Fall Of Math 65daysofstatic 14 2 28
Illmatic Nas 14 2 28
Blood On the Tracks Bob Dylan 9 3 27
Daydream Nation Sonic Youth 8 3 24
If You’re Feeling Sinister Belle & Sebastian 6 4 24
Things We Lost In The Fire Low 8 3 24
The Sophtware Slump Grandaddy 8 3 24
Is This It The Strokes 6 4 24
Abbey Road The Beatles 6 4 24
Highway 61 Revisited Bob Dylan 11 2 22
Emotion Carly Rae Jepsen 11 2 22
Since I Left You The Avalanches 7 3 21
Different Class Pulp 7 3 21
Penguin Eggs Nic Jones 20 1 20
Loveless My Bloody Valentine 5 4 20
Now Kim Jung Mi 20 1 20
United By Fate Rival Schools 5 4 20
Vivadixiesubmarinetransmissionplot Sparklehorse 20 1 20
The Drought Puce Mary 20 1 20
Paris 1919 John Cale 20 1 20
Men’s Needs, Women’s Needs, Whatever The Cribs 20 1 20
The World Is Saved Stina Nordemstan 20 1 20
Bryter Later Nick Drake 20 1 20
Get To Heaven Everything Everything 19 1 19
Untrue Burial 6 3 18
Siamese Dream Smashing Pumpkins 6 3 18
Leaves Turn Inside You Unwound 9 2 18
Fourteen Autumns & Fifteen Winters The Twilight Sad 4 4 16
Double Nickels On The Dime Minutemen 8 2 16
Actually Pet Shop Boys 7 2 14
London Calling The Clash 4 3 12
Superunknown Soundgarden 6 2 12
Ágætis byrjun Sigur Ros 6 2 12
Donuts J Dilla 4 3 12
Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness Smashing Pumpkins 6 2 12
Turn On The Bright Lights Interpol 4 3 12
Burn Piano Island Burn Blood Briothers 6 2 12
Hats The Blue Nile 6 2 12
Marquee Moon Television 6 2 12
Blue Joni Mitchell 6 2 12
Black Love Afghan Whigs 10 1 10
The Milk-Eyed Mender Joanna Newsom 10 1 10
No Shouts, No Calls Electrelane 10 1 10
Treasure Cocteau Twins 10 1 10
After The Goldrush Neil Young 5 2 10
Alexisonfire Alexisonfire 10 1 10
The Lonesome Crowded West Modest Mouse 3 3 9
100 Broken Windows Idlewild 3 3 9
Jane Doe Converge 3 3 9
Relationship Of Command At The Drive-In 3 3 9
Come On Die Young Mogwai 4 2 8
Purple Rain Prince 4 2 8
Frengers Mew 4 2 8
Alien Lanes Guided By Voices 4 2 8
Check Your Head Beastie Boys 8 1 8
Incesticide Nirvana 3 2 6
Drukqs Aphex Twin 3 2 6
The Moon & Antarctica Modest Mouse 3 2 6
Silent Alarm Bloc Party 3 2 6
Nevermind Nirvana 3 2 6
The Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place Explosions In The Sky 3 2 6
Forever Changes Love 3 2 6
Romance Is Boring Los Campesinos! 3 2 6
The Decline Of British Sea Power Sea Power 3 2 6
SAW2 Aphex Twin 3 2 6
Wrong Nomeansno 5 1 5
Calculating Infinity The Dillinger Escape Plan 5 1 5
Without You I’m Nothing Placebo 5 1 5
Rattlesnakes Lloyd Cole & The Commotions 5 1 5
Coles Corner Richard Hawley 5 1 5
Infected The The 5 1 5
Parallel Lines Blondie 5 1 5
Love And Dancing League Unlimited Orchestra 5 1 5
Nite Versions Soulwax 5 1 5
Slanted And Enchanted Pavement 5 1 5
Songs In The Key Of Life Stevie Wonder 5 1 5
Five Leaves Left Nick Drake 5 1 5
Repeater Fugazi 5 1 5
Little Green House Anxious 5 1 5
The White Room KLF 4 1 4
Enter The Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) Wu-Tang Clan 2 2 4
On The Beach Neil Young 2 2 4
Third Portishead 2 2 4
Thunder And Consolation New Model Army 4 1 4
XO Elliott Smith 2 2 4
Doolittle Pixies 2 2 4
Angel Dust Faith No More 2 2 4
Standers Craven Faults 4 1 4
Animals Pink Floyd 4 1 4
Space Is Only Noise Nicolas Jaar 4 1 4
In Utero Nirvana 2 2 4
Machina Smashing Pumpkins 4 1 4
Adore Smashing Pumpkins 4 1 4
Pisces Iscariot Smashing Pumpkins 4 1 4
Original Pirate Material The Streets 2 2 4
Entroducing DJ Shadow 2 2 4
Boxer The National 2 2 4
Capacity Big Thief 2 2 4
As The Roots Undo Circle Takes The Square 4 1 4
You Forgot It In People Broken Social Scene 4 1 4
Who Will Cut Our Hair When We’re Gone The Unicorns 4 1 4
Aquemini OutKast 2 2 4
White Pony Deftones 2 2 4
SAW 85-92 Aphex Twin 2 2 4
Music Has The Right To Children Boards Of Canada 2 2 4
The Holy Bible Manic Street Preachers 2 2 4
Apologies To The Queen Mary Wolf Parade 2 2 4
Keep It Like A Secret Built To Spill 2 2 4
Dopesmoker Sleep 4 1 4
Dirty Mind Prince 4 1 4
Another Green World Brian Eno 2 2 4
Sign O’ The Times Prince 2 2 4
Southernplayalisticadillacmuzik OutKast 4 1 4
Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge Mudhoney 4 1 4
The Woods Sleater-Kinney 4 1 4
Ruins Grouper 4 1 4
Twin Fantasy Car Seat Headrest 4 1 4
Infinity Land Biffy Clyro 4 1 4
Elliott Smith Elliott Smith 3 1 3
The Velvet Underground & Nico The Velvet Underground & Nico 3 1 3
Wild Light 65daysofstatic 3 1 3
We Got It From Here A Tribe Called Quest 3 1 3
Big Time Angel Olsen 3 1 3
Appetite For Destruction Guns n Roses 3 1 3
Nuyorican Soul Nuyorican Soul 3 1 3
Los Angeles Flying Lotus 3 1 3
Jupiter Cave In 3 1 3
() Sigur Ros 3 1 3
Pop 2 Charli XCX 3 1 3
F#A# Godspeed You! Black Emperor 3 1 3
Bee Thousand Guided By Voices 3 1 3
Steve McQueen Prefab Sprout 3 1 3
Principe Del Norte Prins Thomas 3 1 3
The Charlatans The Charlatans 2 1 2
Last Splash The Breeders 2 1 2
4-Track Demos PJ Harvey 2 1 2
The Constant Pageant Trmebling Bells 2 1 2
Treats Sleigh Bells 2 1 2
U.F.Orb The Orb 2 1 2
Sonic Mook Experiment 2: Future Rock & Roll Various 2 1 2
The Queen Is Dead The Smiths 2 1 2
Door Girl Shilpa Ray 2 1 2
Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain Pavement 2 1 2
When I Get Home Solange 2 1 2
Kaputt Destroyer 2 1 2
If I Should Fall From Grace With God The Pogues 2 1 2
Wrecking Ball Emmylou Harris 2 1 2
Onwards And Upwards Culture Shock 2 1 2
Heavy Heavy Young Fathers 2 1 2
Boys For Pele Tori Amos 2 1 2
Prioritise Pleasure Self Esteem 2 1 2
The Race For Space Public Service Broadcasting 2 1 2
The Sunset Tree The Mountain Goats 2 1 2
Hey What Low 2 1 2
Let Them Eat Chaos Kae Tempest 2 1 2
Transangelic Exodus Ezra Furman 2 1 2
Hospice The Antlers 2 1 2
Favourite Worst Nightmare Arctic Monkeys 2 1 2
Wall Of Arms The Maccabees 2 1 2
What’s The Story Morning Glory? Oasis 2 1 2
Songs For The Deaf Queens Of The Stone Age 2 1 2
Celebration Rock Japandroids 2 1 2
This Is Happening LCD Soundsystem 2 1 2
The Bends Radiohead 2 1 2
For Emma, Forever Ago Bon Iver 2 1 2
Screamadelica Primal Scream 2 1 2
The Crane Wife The Decemberists 2 1 2
Heartland Owen Pallett 2 1 2
Life’s Rich Pageant R.E.M. 2 1 2
Anthology Ramones 2 1 2
Supreme Clientele Ghostface Killah 2 1 2
One Of Us Is The Killer Dillinger Escape Plan 2 1 2
Promenade The Divine Comedy 2 1 2
Introspective Pet Shop Boys 2 1 2
Dog Man Star Suede 2 1 2
A Walk Across The Rooftops The Blue Nile 2 1 2
Preteen Weaponry Oneido 2 1 2
The Thing We Make Six By Seven 2 1 2
Travels With Myself And Another Future Of The Left 2 1 2
Masterpiece Big Thief 1 1 1
My War Black Flag 1 1 1
I Don’t Like Shit I Don’t Go Outside Earl Sweatshirt 1 1 1
Stranger In The Alps Phoebe Bridgers 1 1 1
Carrie & Lowell Sufjan Stevens 1 1 1
Mclusky Do Dallas Mclusky 1 1 1
Rounds Four Tet 1 1 1
Tramp Sharon Van Etten 1 1 1
Low Level Owl: Volumes I+II The Appleseed Cast 1 1 1
As Days Get Dark Arab Strap 1 1 1
Chaos A.D. Sepultura 1 1 1
Feast Of Wire Calexico 1 1 1
Sleep And Release Aerogramme 1 1 1
Troublegum Therapy? 1 1 1
Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son Iron Maiden 1 1 1
Hardcore Will Never Die… Mogwai 1 1 1
Everything Must Go Manic Street Preachers 1 1 1
Hate The Delgados 1 1 1
Chopin: The Legendary 1965 Recording Martha Argerich 1 1 1
Rid Of Me PJ Harvey 1 1 1
Neptune’s Lair Drexciya 1 1 1
Suicide: Alan Vega and Martin Rev Suicide 1 1 1
Astral Weeks Van Morrison 1 1 1
White Label Classics Ruff Skwad 1 1 1
Trans Europe Express Kraftwerk 1 1 1
Have One On Me Joanna Newsom 1 1 1
Only Built For Cuban Linx Raekwon 1 1 1
Bela Bartok: The String Quartets Tokyo String Quartet 1 1 1
Slates The Fall 1 1 1
Boy In Da Corner Dizzee Rascal 1 1 1
The Immaculate Collection Madonna 1 1 1
Tago Mago Can 1 1 1
Slow Riot For New Zero Kanada Godspeed You! Black Emperor 1 1 1
We’re New Here Gil Scott Heron & Jamie XX 1 1 1
Dance Music Mastersystem 1 1 1
Live At The Witch Trials The Fall 1 1 1
Teens Of Denial Car Seat Headrest 1 1 1
Box Car Racer Box Car Racer 1 1 1
It’s A Shame About Ray The Lemonheads 1 1 1
Geogaddi Boards Of Canada 1 1 1
Reinventing Axl Rose Against Me! 1 1 1
Wu-Tang Meets The Indie Culture Wu-Tang Clan 1 1 1
Those Who Tell The Truth Shall Die… Explosions In The Sky 1 1 1
One Time For All Time 65daysofstatic 1 1 1
Blink-182 Blink-182 1 1 1
I Was Here For A Moment… Maybeshewill 1 1 1
Special Moves Mogwai 1 1 1
What The Toll Tells Two Gallants 1 1 1
Reign In Blood Slayer 1 1 1
Remain In Light Talking Heads 1 1 1
Low David Bowie 1 1 1
Static Age Misfits 1 1 1
The Downward Spiral Nine Inch Nails 1 1 1
Richard D. James Album Aphex Twin 1 1 1
Either/Or Elliott Smith 1 1 1
Hidden World Fucked Up 1 1 1
1989 Taylor Swift 1 1 1
Spite House Spite House 1 1 1
Vestli Spielbergs 1 1 1
By The Way Red Hot Chilli Peppers 1 1 1
The Frankenstein Effect Mutation 1 1 1
The National Health Maximo Park 1 1 1
American Idiot Green Day 1 1 1
Into Red FEWS 1 1 1
Cheer Drug Church 1 1 1
Hysteria Def Leppard 1 1 1
Hey Everyone Dananananaykroyd 1 1 1
Gris Klein Birds In Row 1 1 1
Buffalo Skinners Big Country 1 1 1
Reckless Bryan Adams 1 1 1
The Low End Theory A Tribe Called Quest 1 1 1
The Infamous Mobb Depp 1 1 1
Master Of Puppets Metallica 1 1 1
The Man Machine Kraftwerk 1 1 1
Demon Days Gorillaz 1 1 1
Fire Like This Blood Red Shoes 1 1 1
Beaucoup Fish Underworld 1 1 1
Graceland Paul Simon 1 1 1
A Love Supreme John Coltrane 1 1 1
Oceanic ISIS 1 1 1
Labor Days Aesop Rock 1 1 1
Substrata Biosphere 1 1 1
I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning Bright Eyes 1 1 1
The Execution Of All Things Rilo Kiley 1 1 1
Under The Bushes, Under The Stars Guided By Voices 1 1 1
Emergency & I The Dismemberment Plan 1 1 1
Worry Jeff Rosenstock 1 1 1
New Adventures In HiFi R.E.M. 1 1 1
Ladies & Gentlemen We Are Floating In Space Spiritualized 1 1 1
Illinois Sufjan Stevens 1 1 1
Turn Out The Lights Julien Baker 1 1 1
Trick Alex G 1 1 1
Sera Que Ahora Podremos Entendernos Mabe Fratti 1 1 1
Alopecia Why? 1 1 1
Surfer Rosa Pixies 1 1 1
Copia Eluvium 1 1 1
Brighten The Corners Pavement 1 1 1
The Tired Sounds Of Stars Of The Lid Stars Of The Lid 1 1 1
Run Come Save Me Roots Manuva 1 1 1
All Hail West Texas The Mountain Goats 1 1 1
Funeral Arcade Fire 1 1 1
It’s Hard To Find A Friend Pedro The Lion 1 1 1
Lifted… Bright Eyes 1 1 1
The Lost Riots Hope Of The States 1 1 1
The Great Destroyer Low 1 1 1
Document R.E.M. 1 1 1
Transatlanticism Death Cab For Cutie 1 1 1
The Monitor Titus Andronicus 1 1 1
The End Of History Fionn Regan 1 1 1
Punisher Phoebe Bridgers 1 1 1
folklore Taylor Swift 1 1 1
Danger Days: True Lives Of The Fabulous Killjoys My Chemical Romance 1 1 1
Melodrama Lorde 1 1 1
Renaissance Beyoncé 1 1 1
The Age Of Adz Sufjan Stevens 1 1 1
Whack World Tierra Whack 1 1 1
A Seat At The Table Solange 1 1 1
Trout Mask Replica Captain Beefheart 1 1 1
Mama’s Gun Erykah Badu 1 1 1
Solid Air John Martyn 1 1 1
Oh My God, Charlie Darwin The Low Anthem 1 1 1
16 Lovers Lane The Go-Betweens 1 1 1
Secret South 16 Horsepower 1 1 1
The Fool Warpaint 1 1 1
Love Songs For Underdogs Tanya Donnelly 1 1 1
Something To Write Home About The Get Up Kids 1 1 1
With A Lot O’ Soul The Temptations 1 1 1
Are We There Sharon Van Etten 1 1 1
Today’s Empires, Tomorrow’s Ashes Propaghandi 1 1 1
The Felice Brothers The Felice Brothers 1 1 1
Ctrl SZA 1 1 1
Daydream Mariah Carey 1 1 1
Gentlemen Afghan Whigs 1 1 1
MOTOMAMI Rosalia 1 1 1
Dead Reckoning Small Brown Bike 1 1 1
Our Endless Numbered Days Iron & Wine 1 1 1
Bossanova Pixies 1 1 1
Vienna Ultravox 1 1 1
Red Medicine Fugazi 1 1 1
Locust Abortion Technician Butthole Surfers 1 1 1
The English Riviera Metronomy 1 1 1
Compro Skee Mask 1 1 1
Happy Songs For Happy People Mogwai 1 1 1
Parklife Blur 1 1 1
Violator Depeche Mode 1 1 1
Juju Siouxsie & The Banshees 1 1 1
Fever Ray Fever Ray 1 1 1
Dubnobasswithmyheadman Underworld 1 1 1
Philophobia Arab Strap 1 1 1
His n Hers Pulp 1 1 1
Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix Phoenix 1 1 1
Silent Shout The Knife 1 1 1
The Shape of Punk To Come Refused 1 1 1
A Song To Ruin Million Dead 1 1 1
Peasant Richard Dawson 1 1 1
Homogenic Bjork 1 1 1
You’re Living All Over Me Dinosaur Jr 1 1 1
The Hissing Of Summer Lawns Joni Mitchell 1 1 1
Automatic For The People R.E.M. 1 1 1
Eat A Peach Allman Brothers Band 1 1 1
The Paul Simon Songbook Paul Simon 1 1 1
Zeit Tangerine Dream 1 1 1
Madonna Madonna 1 1 1
Desire Bob Dylan 1 1 1
Loaded The Velvet Underground 1 1 1
Time Out Dave Brubeck Quartet 1 1 1
Deep Listening Pauline Oliveros 1 1 1
Tonights The Night Neil Young 1 1 1
Comes A Time Neil Young 1 1 1
Harvest Neil Young 1 1 1
Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere Neil Young 1 1 1
Luxury Problems Andy Stott 1 1 1
2 Meat Puppets 1 1 1
Moya EP Godspeed You! Black Emperor 1 1 1
Dummy Portishead 1 1 1
Sonic Youth EP Sonic Youth 1 1 1
Pink Moon Nick Drake 1 1 1
Tabula Rasa & Symphony No. 3 Arvo Part 1 1 1
Calling Out Of Context Arthur Russell 1 1 1
Hex, or Printing in the Infernal Method Earth 1 1 1
Bert Jansch Bert Jansch
Raime EP Raime
I Care Because You Do Aphex Twin
And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out Yo La Tengo
Heart Food Judee Sill
In The Court Of The Crimson King King Crimson
Worship And Tribute Glassjaw
Voodoo D’Angelo
Vespertine Bjork
Kind Of Blue Miles Davis
Yankee Hotel Foxtrot Wilco
Stop Making Sense Talking Heads
In Rainbows Radiohead
9 Likes

think this is the furthest up the list where I’ve absolutely no idea what it is, so going with this one

8 Likes

Any chance of hiding this behind the drop down option? Just a longgg one to scroll

2 Likes

More general canon classics are fine too, I’m sure I first heard Ziggy Stardust this way in that old thread

Though obvs the dissier the better

Wow, I’m surprised! Feels like one of those truly inescapable names/stories

It’s a banger

3 Likes

22 tracks! that’s certainly a number