Yeah, probably a topic for another thread since I can write volumes on this, but I think his post-reunion output gets treated unfairly for the most part, Oceania and Zeitgeist especially. (Not to say there aren’t valid criticisms - new vocal style, vocals pushed up front, phoned in lyrics in the case of Monuments, etc.). But even back with Adore and Machina (and even Mellon Collie) there were some really negative takes that probably took a few years off of my life.
I think we agree actually - it might just be one of those situations where an album gets a different grade whether reviewed on its merit as a standalone album vs. in the context of the band’s history. If this were the first time I had heard them I’d be pretty excited. I definitely would have liked them to have pushed things more, but at the same time it’s still another 30 minutes of METZ doing their thing and until now we’ve only had an hour of that.