Boxer is just Alligator with worse songs. High Violet is better than Boxer but doesn’t have the consistency of Alligator. Trouble Will Find Me was kinda weak, pretty dull. Their Debut is straight up bad and Sad Songs For Dirty Lovers was an indicator for the great Alligator, but not as great as the great Alligator.
I think the new one ranks between High Violet and Boxer because as I say Boxer is just Alligator with worse songs