Alright here we go:
Is Should Live In Salt - Bad, the āYou should know me better than thatā bit is extended a beat too long IMO and it genuinely irritates me as a result
Demons - Donāt like how he sings āThe cityā at the start, it reminds me of Flight of the Conchords, thereās a few bits where there are too many syllables for the lyrics to scan properly, annoys me.
Donāt Swallow the Cap - Better than the first two but I find it a bit pedestrian
Fireproof - Donāt mind it in and of itself, itās kind of almost an equivalent to City Middle or something in terms of the function that song serves in pacing Alligator but without anything good enough surrounding it to not just be a bit dull
Sea of Love - Actually good
Heavenfaced - Got that awful rhyming dictionary bit (there are a few bits like that on the record in general)
This Is The Last Time - He sounds bored
Graceless - Good song (This is giving the impression that I only like up-tempo National songs but this really isnāt the case) still a bit rhyming dictionary-ish though
Slipped - Itās alright, again, thereās just too many songs with this down-tempo, pedestrian vibe on the record for them not to merge into each other where they donāt do that on the other albums
I Need My Girl - Donāt know why he sings ālaugh about in front of familyā like some kind of southern hick
Humiliation - Again, just very pedestrian and by-the numbers
Pink Rabbits - Really good
Hard to Find - Possibly the most disappointing thing about the album, they always close brilliantly up until this point. This just whimpers out.
In summary, itās as disappointing as I remember it being and I should do some work.