The logic, I guess, is the one time heās looked remotely like a test opener was in Asian conditions so either he can find some form or completely make up the selectors minds.
I disagree though obviously. the ashes are being played here, Starc is better than anything Indian seamer, not sure who the openers can be for the ashes but he definitely canāt be one of them, so weāve got 6 matches to have a look at burns, Gubbins and maybe stoneman/denly.
Everytime I go through the options Iām more convinced cook hasnāt played his last test match for England