People who have been in good bands and bad bands

We will accept as touring members/album contributors

Dave Grohl
Good band: Nirvana
Bad band: Foo Fighters

Flea
Good band:Jane’s Addiction, Mars Volta
Bad band: RHCP

John Power
Good band: Cast
Bad band : The La’s

2 Likes

David Pajo;
Good - Zwan
Bad - Tortoise

10 Likes

David Pajo, loads of both but

Good:
Slint

Bad:
Zwan

2 Likes

lolz

3 Likes

Paul McCartney.

Good band: Wings
Bad band: The Beatles.

From Alan Partridge

7 Likes

Mick Jagger

Bad band: The Rolling Stones

Good band:

2 Likes

All of them except for Zach de la rocha

Good: rage against the machine

Bad: audioslave

3 Likes

David Bowie

Good : David Bowie
Bad : Tin Machine

6 Likes

James Murphy
Good band: Pony
Bad band: LCD Soundsystem

Good : Modest Mouse
Bad : The Smiths

Johnny Marr

10 Likes

Brian Cook:
Good - Botch, TAAS, Sumac,
Bad - Russian Circles!!

4 Likes

And the Cribs for good

1 Like

Russian Circles aren’t that bad!

5 Likes

they are probably fine really, but I would rather he spent time on almost any of his other projects! (I did walk out on them on a TAAS / Russian Circles tour because they wound me up/bored me at the time, but that was probably entirely on me…)

My favourite member of David Bowie was David Bowie

7 Likes

What a coincidence, mine too! :wink:

“I’m going to see the band David Bowie”
“Who are the members?”
“Well, there’s David Bowie…and…”

1 Like

Errrrr Mick Ronson? :joy:

1 Like

And

Not sure I can cope with two such spicy takes one after another.

12 Likes

Well I guess that’s alright, I guess that’s alriiiiight

4 Likes