Pinkerton or The Blue Album

Seems like as good a topic as any to test the new forum with.

Pinkerton, obvs.

1 Like

Pinkerton.

/thread

Tryhards, both of you. It’s Blue.

4 Likes

Yeah, it’s Blue.

Hurley

5 Likes

Hard to say, both are equally poor.

Have never been able to figure out if this is just a DIS running joke I don’t get or a real thing that I don’t get.

Wheatus

Blue, because Pinkerton has The Good Life on

Blue - 19/10
Pinkerton 7/10

1 Like

that was meant to be 9/10, but fuck it 19 it is!

2 Likes

I used to think this was like some sort of unanswerable question and that anyone would be stupid for being able to pick one over the other.

I’ve listened to a lot of Weezer recently and I’ve come to the realization that Pinkerton is quite a lot weaker than Blue and I think I have even started to prefer the White Album over Pinkerton.

So… yea

1 Like

Actually, it’s easily Blue for the B sides as well - Jamie and Mykel and Carli are BELTERS

  • Blue
  • Pinkerton

0 voters

'zactly man. anyone who says otherwise is just trying waaaaaay too hard

Mykel & Carli, Jamie and Susanne vs You Gave Your Love To Me Softly, Devotion and I Just Threw Out The Love Of My Dreams…

I’d say the battle of the B-Sides is a tougher call than arguing which album is best!

You mean because only a cloth-eared idiot would pick Pinkerton over Blue?

THIS!

I’ve had White on unbelievably heavy rotation since it came out in April, and I’m ready to go on record as saying.

Blue > White > Pinkerton

There must be more of us.

1 Like

*The Wheatus