Been loving the Lonesome Dove series (Larry McMurty). I just need to get Comanche Moon.
Butchers Crossing - John Williams - is a good one.
Wasn’t sure about Blood Meridian - Cormac McCarthy.
Want to get hold of Warlock by Oakley Hall. Finding it weirdly difficult to get hold of - just bought a french translation off ebay by mistake. So need to either learn french or keep looking.
The Heart in Winter by Kevin Barry. I guess it’s not strictly a Western, but set in 1890s Montana and has that kind of vibe. Remember it being also very funny.
I don’t read a lot of westerns but I read a lot of western adjacent books i.e. rural noir and post- apocalyptic stuff (which are essentially westerns with zombies). I’ve read many of Joe R Lansdale’s books, he writes in several genres but ‘The Thicket’ and ‘Paradise Sky’ are great westerns.
I’ll give a nudge for Tom’s Crossing, even though it’s set in the 1980s. A lot of horses and guns involved. Brilliant book, definitely made me want to read some more western type books - still need to attempt Lonesome Dove the next time I’m ready for a big book.
Not exactly a deep cut but I’m reading East of Eden atm. It’s certainly way better written and more nuanced than Of Mice & Men. Still easy to read while being pretty insightful though, enjoyable characters too so yeah, it’s great so far tbh. It is a chonky boy though, will easily last me a few months.
Not really what you asked for, but I read Beartooth by Callan Wink last year and enjoyed it. It’s set in the present day so doesn’t count as a western, but it very much has the vibe of one - people living off the land, outlaw types, hunting etc. lots of good wilderness writing. A ’modern day Western’ if you will.
I’ve been rereading all of The Dark Tower this year, and they are very very Western, especially Wolves Of The Calla, which is the story of how some gunslingers help a poor agricultural village fend off persistent bandit attacks (before anyone goes ah, but Battle Beyond The Stars isn’t a Western is it, it’s full of horses and ranches and arroyos and dust clouds and all that stuff) (plus the village is literally named after John Sturges)