I wasn’t really excited for a Spoon album either…until I heard Do You and it piqued my interest.
I think my one criticism of Spoon is, for all their consistency and excellent songwriting, they struggle to strike up an atmosphere in quite the way the same way some of their contemporaries do. A better way of saying might be that Spoon sound like a composite of the best bits of other bands.
Basically I get what you mean by “being in the mood” for a Spoon record, even if I can’t articulate it very well.