The Greatest* Albums Of All Time - a DiS listening club! šŸ’æ CURRENT ALBUM: FRANK OCEAN - BLOND šŸ’æ

Testify was very good, Street Fighter Mas was solid

think i’d like any one of these tracks in isolation, but even an hour of it would be too much for me - never mind double that

will let Connections play out since it’s started, then i’m probably out for this one!

If I could chop the album in half, this would have been decent:

  1. Fists of Fury
  2. Can You Hear Him
  3. Connections
  4. One of One
  5. The Space Traveller’s Lullaby
  6. Street Fighter Mas
  7. Song for the Fallen
  8. Will You Sing

Had the same problem with The Epic. For every moment of brilliance there’s so much stuffed in to give the impression of making a grand statement when really Washington and the band have enough talent to make a shorter album (that’s still very long) with more impact. I agree with @Ombudsman that the second half of Can You Hear Him is a highlight, and the proggy solo in Will You Sing which is one of the better vocal tracks. At it’s worst there’s so much going on (solos! choir! strings overpowering the choir!) and little to remember.

Worse ways to pass two and a half hours, but doubt I’ll be listening from beginning to end again

2 Likes

Good lord this is not for me. Was determined to finish it, but 3 tracks was too much. For me.

2 Likes

The secret third disc is also on streaming but as a separate album.

Harmony of Difference is probably my favourite thing he’s done, need to dig it out

2 Likes

I might be the only one, but I think this album is amazing as it is, and it works for me at that length. I think it’s a consistently excellent record which would rightly sit on a best 100 jazz albums list (if not quite my cross-genre all time 100).

Placed this 6th on my list for the year at the time but it would likely be higher on replay (think having got more into jazz of all eras and styles far more in the years since has only made me appreciate this album more.

Also enjoying the Jane’s Addiction album. Have only heard one song of theirs before, think this album sounds great in terms of playing and production, though I could leave the vocals.

4 Likes

Yeah this is the one I have, I can’t really cope with the 3hr ones but this one I absolutely love.

If you weren’t into it, no one on this site would be. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

I love Heaven and Earth as well. I think I prefer The Epic but that is because I listened to it a lot more than Heaven and Earth.

I have a slight issue with the production on his stuff, though. It is a bit ā€˜wall of sound’ without the space and dynamics that I love in the best jazz recordings (the Alice Coltrane album later in the list is a good example of the sort of production I love). Not enough to put me off it though.

Felt the same the couple of times I have seen him live, it was all a bit loud and raucous compared to my ideal. Still really good live but not quite as brilliant an experience as I would have liked it to be.

1 Like

You say that, but it was the winner (jointly, with Lets Eat Grandma) of the June 2018 album of the month poll on here and I didn’t even vote in that thread! We may have had some turnover since then to be fair.

1 Like

Really enjoyed The Epic and he put on a great show at The Auditorium at Primavera which was the perfect venue for him.

Never actually got round to listening to this one as I felt I’d heard enough of him just by listening to The Epic. Will give it a spin.

You have to listen to the 2hr24min of notes that he isn’t playing

6 Likes

There aren’t that many notes he isn’t playing, tbf

12 Likes

Right - I have listened to both discs plus the secret third disc!

Thoughts:

  • I much preferred disc two to disc one. It was still a bit of a sprawl but in a more pleasant, melodic way. Street Fighter Mas is a particular highlight
  • the third disc was pleasant enough (the cover of Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow was alright) for what presumably was made up of outtakes
  • I think a lot of it boils down to not really liking the saxophone as a solo instrument. I much preferred the trumpet / piano / synth solo parts.
  • as someone said upthread, a 7-8 track version of the album would be a really decent 50-60 minutes listen. But I don’t think I’d sit through the whole three hours (including disc three) again.
  • that said, he’s clearly talented, and I might dip into some of the recommended albums upthread
1 Like

I liked this. I’ve only listened to disc one, and I’m not sure I’ll ever sit down and listen to it front to back, but there’s lots to enjoy. Might save a playlist of his stuff and whack it on at work when I’m struggling to concentrate.

dipped a toe into this while i was walking the dog and found myself skipping tracks at about the 4 min mark. just not a fan of solos tbh. Connections is cool, more laid back and vibey, less anxiety inducing. i’ll press on but there’s no chance im listening to the whole thing

I meant to do a new album today. Tomorrow it is!

2 Likes

Yes, this. I don’t think it’s helped by the compressed mastering on his albums, either.

SAULT seem to be able to have an orchestra, choir, batacuda drumming etc often on the same track, but their music still has space and range; whereas with Washington’s stuff it often feels like he’s just shouting at you.

2 Likes

Not much to add to previous reviews. Struggled to actively listen to this album and found it fading into background noise quite a bit. Feel like most tracks have some interesting stuff going on, but not enough to justify eight or nine minute run times. Think that the saxophone tends to be the least interesting bit of most of the songs. Can’t see myself revisiting this one…

Okay, it’s time for a new album! This time, it’s

TAYLOR SWIFT - RED

"Rolling Stone summary

Taylor Swift shocked the world with her fourth album, breaking away from country music to make a record that recalled classics by the Beatles and Prince in the way it pulled from across the pop and rock landscape and transformed every sound it touched. The lead single, ā€œWe Are Never Ever Getting Back Together,ā€ was stomping, swaying electro-twang. ā€œI Know You Were Troubleā€ rode a dubstep groove, and the title track was a swirl of banjos, dusty guitars, and talk-box elation. Tabloid types tied themselves in knots trying to figure out which song was about which ex, but the real news was Swift’s songwriting on high points like the astonishing ā€œAll Too Well,ā€ as vivid a post-breakup remembrance as any artist has ever produced.

I’m making the call to listen to Taylor’s Version but only as far as the original track listing, otherwise I’m looking at 2h10m, which is a bit much for me. Happy for you to do as you please!

1 Like