My point was more that it still fits on one disc, so nothing lost + sounds great (the most recent Joyce Manor was produced by Kurt Ballou).
It is possible that this applies more to the less-heavy stuff you’re citing here? I think producers with ‘a sound’ are a double-edged sword, and genre tends to reveal that.
I mean there’s a few factors undoubtedly - I get the impression that Kele was overbearing once they got successful and a couple of the other members just got fed up of it in the end.
But that four-piece had more great music in them, they had to have.
Blue Record is also fantastic. With a lot of the more recent Congleton produced albums I haven’t really liked (Angel Olsen, Sharon van Etten, Baroness amongst others) the production isn’t my biggest issue with any of them. He produced The Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place, so he can have a pass form me pretty much forever.