Whilst I wouldn’t agree with Sean that Burst Apart is the best indie rock album of the decade, I would second the suggestion that it’s the Antler’s best album by a stretch.
It does perhaps lack the cohesion of Hospice and Familiars, but the clincher is that the songwriting is consistently at a higher level on Burst Apart than it is on the other records, silly trumpet interlude aside. I’d say the majority of tracks on Burst Apart are at least as good as Hospice and Familiars’ peaks (Kettering, Epilogue, Palace, Hotel), and then the standout tracks (I don’t want love, Putting the dog to sleep) are at an even higher level.
You’re right to a degree about No Widows though. Live version is amazing (though I continue to like the studio version)
Hospice is a great record, but it was released in 2009.
Best College Prog album released from 2010-present?
All 5-stars:
Hotel of the Laughing Tree - Terror and Everything After
Pepe Deluxe - Queen of the Wave
Small Leaks Sink Ships - Face Yourself and Remove Your Sandals
Got it - can’t say I agree but I think it’s always a healthy sign when a band has 3 or more albums which are genuinely believed to be their best work by large parts of the fan base
I just can’t get into Familiars. It has special moments but as a whole gets too bogged down for my liking. Also thought a lot of it sounded better live than the recorded versions