To The Bone (Content Warning: ED #SSP)


#1

Trigger warning for Eating Disorders

I’ve been reading some things about the new Netflix series coming out this week and it seems somewhat troublesome.

Here is the trailer if you’d like to watch it.

It seems Netflix are going through a phase of glamourizing mental health issues (see 13 Reasons Why). I can definitely see some issues in the trailer of the whole thing seeming twee and dream-like, which is probably quite aspiration for teens. It’s super concerning that Lily Collin’s has had ED problems in the past and she has lost a ton of weight for this role.
Will you be watching?


#2

probably not


#3

Calling it ‘To the Bone’ seems a bit on the nose too.


#4

Ooooft yep makes me feel incredibly weird thinking about this sort of thing.


#5

Yeah.
You only have to search for it on twitter to see a fair few people being like “She is thinspo” or “she looks amazing”.


#6

Ah that’s really heartbreaking.


#7

fucking hell :disappointed::worried:


#8

Sorry if I’m being stupid but what does thinspo mean?


#9

Thinspiration I think, meow?


#10

Yeah, that’s what it means.


#11

Then why isn’t it thinspi?


#12

Hmmm I really feel like I don’t really know enough about this to form a cogent opinion. I suppose my question would be what should the aims of any fictional series tackling mental illness be? Or even what are the tropes to avoid?


#13

A lot of people with eating disorders are going to be triggered by any media which depicts those illnesses so it’s always going to receive a backlash, but I think people’s main problem with To The Bone is that it seems to be perpetuating the trope of extreme thinness as the standard for EDs.

It’s not intrinsically inaccurate or misleading to have a character with anorexia be that thin, obviously, but it’s probably unhelpful given that there’s a big problem with the competitiveness of eating disorders and people feeling invalid due to not fitting the stereotypes, so this kind of thing can heavily exacerbate dangerous feelings. Something in the mass media which presents different ED realities, even if triggering, would be embraced a lot more I think.

Worth noting that the director has a history of the illness so it’s not like it’s just being co-opted for edgy content, and the intent is stated as promoting recovery.


#14

Think this comes across as more negative and critical than I was intending. I’m sure they meant well and obviously felt they had their own story to tell. Hope it’s good and helps some people.


#15

This is true, it would have been so much more powerful if they used a girl in the early stages of anorexia. She won’t look drammatically thin or could even be overweight - intervention is always best in the beginning but because the NHS can’t afford to treat a patient with a normal BMI for anorexia, these are the ones who are at so much risk but are ultimately left to their own devices (and end up dangerously underweight/deeply depressed or suicidal etc)


#16

things have changed so much from when most of us here were teenagers, the work I’ve done with youth projects etc made me realise how horribly affected they are by the fact they’ve grown up with computers and everything that entails. I hated being a teenager up until I was about 17 and I can’t imagine how much worse it would have been with social media


#17

yeah it sounds a bit like this

http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/tv-radio/2017/01/ten-years-how-cassie-skins-eating-disorder-affected-generation-teenage

the thing that annoys me about stuff like this is thinking that the producers knew they were dealing with somthing that could potentially harm viewers, knew that there are organisations out there with expertise and chose not to contact them.


#18

Yeah, absolutely this. Someone close to me has struggled with ED for years, and media which reaffirmed stereotypes of what anorexia sufferers should look like were just incredibly harmful influences, and often triggered obsessive rewatching or mimicking… we’re not really in touch anymore, but when I saw the advert for To The Bone, I really hoped that she wouldn’t watch it…


#19

To clarify: I’m not saying that To The Bone is going to be like a pro-ana advert, or that it isn’t going to have nuance - it’s just that I knew that she (and other people suffering from ED) have the tendency to pick out visual elements which promote their illness.


#20

Because: