Did this too. Been quite a few years since the idea of “all-time favourites” has made much sense to me. Started writing up a list of the old favourites, but then dropped anything I hadn’t actually listened to for more than a couple of years. Kinda ended up with a group of about six albums (strictly one album per artist), then a gap to the next level with far too many candidates to narrow down to the four needed to round out the list.:
The Cure — Faith*
Pixies — Doolittle
Smashing Pumpkins — Siamese Dream
Underground Lovers — Dream It Down**
Kylie Minogue — Impossible Princess
Bloc Party — Silent Alarm
Feels odd to have so few female vocalists, seeing as I generally prefer them to male vocals…
*Always used to be Disintegration, but I’m far more likely to put on Faith, or 17 Seconds or Pornography nowadays.
**Hard to choose between this and Leaves Me Blind.