What’s Their Best Song? #3: The Beatles - RESULTS THREAD

Well here we go then, there was a huge response to this one and a lot to get through so apologies if we run into a second day but I do have to do some work around this which is quite frankly out of order.

104 songs, 75 sets of votes, 1 winner. Let’s go.

20 Likes

OH BOY

This post paid for by PROF$.

4 Likes

That’s by Buddy Holly actually. (5/5)

7 Likes

Here, in joint 78th place, are all the song with 1 POINT

Ask Me Why
Sun King
Mean Mr. Mustard
Polythene Pam
When I’m 64
Oh! Darling
It Won’t Be Long
Good Day Sunshine
PS I Love You
It’s All Too Much
Sexy Sadie
Everybody’s Got Something To Hide Except Me & My Monkey
Magical Mystery Tour
I’ve Got A Feeling
I Me Mine
Not A Second Time
Julia
You Won’t See Me
We Can Work It Out
Hello Goodbye
If I Needed Someone
The Ballad Of John & Yoko
Any Time At All
Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
Think For Yourself
Blue Jay Way
Love You To

5 Likes

Maxwell’s Silver Hammer at number 1? Right? RIGHT???

A bloodbath.

This post paid for by PROF$.

5 Likes

Wait, WHAT?

This post paid for by PROF$.

5 Likes

Are you shocked that it got just one point, or that it got one point at all? It’s one of mine.

1 Like

Nearly had Julia for one of my votes. Definitely one of the best of the more ‘mature’(?) type of songs. sad and sweet too.

2 Likes

I nearly gave it lots of points, but I forgot

Wow!
Thought LSD would have been much higher

csi miami GIF

5 Likes

Nice to see Radiohead out of the running already with Sexy Sadie.

4 Likes

It’s all too much!!! (one point)

1 Like

all mine

surprised no one else voted for Blue Jay Way

not surprised about the other 2

Poor George

1 Like

hate these songs so much

5 Likes

Forgot to vote. Fuck it all.

2 Likes

In joint 65th place, these songs all have 2 POINTS

Flying
No Reply
Because
Getting Better
Rocky Raccoon
I’m So Tired
Girl
Birthday
You Never Give Me Your Money
The End
A Hard Day’s Night
Fool On The Hill
Within You Without You

3 Likes

Shocked that it got only one!

This post paid for by PROF$.

1 Like

Don’t think I’ve ever heard it

Should be top 20 at least.

6 Likes